City Commission Packet 02-10-2015

View the PDF version Google Docs PDF Viewer

    CITY OF MUSKEGON
      CITY COMMISSION MEETING
                   FEBRUARY 10, 2015
   CITY COMMISSION CHAMBERS @ 5:30 P.M.
                              AGENDA

□ CALL TO ORDER:
□ PRAYER:
□ PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE:
□ ROLL CALL:
□ HONORS AND AWARDS:
□ INTRODUCTIONS/PRESENTATION:
□ CITY MANAGER’S REPORT:
□ CONSENT AGENDA:
     A. Approval of Minutes. CITY CLERK
     B. Purchase of Vacant Land at 2112 Sampson Street. CNS
     C. 2015 Dozer Rental for Beach Leveling. DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC WORKS
     D. KEPS Technologies, Inc. Telecommunications Permit. ENGINEERING
     E. Management Agreement – Fisherman’s Landing. FINANCE
     F. Banking Services RFP. FINANCE
□ PUBLIC HEARINGS:
□ COMMUNICATIONS:
□ UNFINISHED BUSINESS:
□ NEW BUSINESS:
     A. Approval of Sale of City-Owned Home at 1581 Division. CNS
     B. Amendment to the Rental Property Ordinance. PUBLIC SAFETY
     C. Consideration of Bids for Muskegon/Webster Avenue from 9th to Spring.
        ENGINEERING
Memorandum 
To:    Mayor and Commissioners 

From:  Frank Peterson 

Re:    City Commission Meeting 

Date:  February 10, 2015 

We have a number of items on the agenda, and I thought you could use a little background on some of 
them as you prepare for our meeting next week. 

1.     One the Work Session: 
       a. Staff is in receipt of a request for a PILOT request to accommodate a senior facility at 30 E. 
           Clay.  The requestor (General Capital) will be in attendance to provide the commission with 
           a  presentation  of  their  plans  for  the  site.    This  is  a  tricky  item  for  staff,  but  at  this  point, 
           staff  is  recommending  approval  of  the  PILOT.    This  is  done  with  the  conditions  that  they 
           include  at  least  2  market  rate  units  in  the  development  and  that  they  provide  funds  for 
           escrow,  equal  to  the  estimated  cost  for  the  building  demolition,  with  the  demolition  to 
           occur  no  later  than  Nov.  30,  2015  (if  not,  the  funds  may  be  taken  out  of  escrow  and  the 
           City can proceed with the demolition).  Staff would also like authorization to negotiate with 
           General  Capital  on  the  details  of  the  Contract  Agreement  (including  PILOT  amount)  for 
           presentation to the City Commission on March 10th.   
            
           This  group  originally  approached  staff  looking  for  input  into  potential  locations  for  their 
           project.  We highly recommended 30 E. Clay, as we view the property as blighted, difficult 
           for  redevelopment,  and  very  likely  to  become  a  long‐term  cost  for  the  city  as  we  pursue 
           demolition.    Staff’s  recommendation  for  approval  is  partly  based  on  the  site’s  location 
           being  outside  of  the  immediate  downtown  area  where  market  rate  housing  is  most 
           needed.    We  also  feel  that  as  a  senior  project,  it  will  have  a  negligible  impact  on  the 
           planned  market‐rate  housing  and  existing  income‐based  housing  in  the  downtown.  
           Further,  we  are  very  encouraged  by  their  location  selection,  as  the  project  will  vastly 
           improve a blighted property in a highly visible section of the city, which will greatly add to 
           the  development  in  this  area  of  downtown  (the  property  is  adjacent  to  the  newly 
           renovated United Way Complex). 
            
2.     Under the consent agenda, we are asking the Commission to approve: 
       a. Last meeting’s minutes. 
       b. The purchase of a vacant lot at 2112 Sampson Street, when we intend to construct a sing‐
           family  home  via  the  HOME  Program.    This  will  help  meet  our  program’s  goal  of  helping 
            low/moderate  income  families  enter  into  neighborhoods  that  otherwise  would  not  be 
            accessible because of affordability.   
        c. Rental of a dozer for beach leveling – this is an annual expense. 
        d. Permit to install telecommunications within the right‐of‐way.  This is a Metro Act approval, 
            and  simply  a  technicality  for  the  commission,  as  we  do  not  have  standing  to  deny  such 
            installations in the right‐of‐way. 
        e. A new 5‐year management agreement for Fisherman’s Landing.  Last year was a great year 
            for the campground.  We were able to mutually work through a number of issues from the 
            previous years, and are much more comfortable with a long‐term arrangement vs. the one‐
            year agreement we approved last year. 
        f. A new agreement with Fifth Third to provide banking services.  This is a renewal following 
            an RFP process.  The approved bank must have a presence in the City of Muskegon.  
3.      Under Hearings/Other/New Business we have four topics for discussion: 
        a. Approval  of  the  sale  of  1581  Division.    This  is  the  last  CNS  home  available  –  so,  we’re  all 
            sold out  
        b. Approval of an amendment to the Rental Property Ordinance to fix two errors found after 
            the  Commission’s  recent  approval  of  the  fire  insurance  requirement.    We  did  also  look 
            internally  at  the  potential  of  adding  a  requirement  that  landlords  notify  tenants  of  their 
            need for renters insurance, but at this point are not recommending such an addition – after 
            consulting  with  the  City  Attorney,  we  feel  that  the  requirement  would  not  be  readily 
            enforceable unless we required a staff review of every lease agreement.   
        c. Authorization  to  award  the  Muskegon/Webster  reconstruction  project  to  the  lowest 
            responsible  bidder  –  Jackson‐Merkey  Contractors  in  Muskegon  Township.    Their  base  bid 
            was $4,367,400.55, but we would like the authorization to identify some areas of their bid 
            to speak with them to potentially adjust/change/remove to help us move closer to our $3.3 
            Million  grant  award.    The  engineer’s  estimate  received  in  October  was  $5.185  Million,  so 
            this bid is actually $817,000 under that estimate. 

If there are questions on any agenda items, please try to let staff know in advance, and we will be sure 
to have the appropriate data/research available at the meeting. 
□ ANY OTHER BUSINESS:
□ PUBLIC PARTICIPATION:
►   Reminder: Individuals who would like to address the City Commission shall do the following:
►   Fill out a request to speak form attached to the agenda or located in the back of the room.
►   Submit the form to the City Clerk.
►   Be recognized by the Chair.
►   Step forward to the microphone.
►   State name and address.
►   Limit of 3 minutes to address the Commission.
►   (Speaker representing a group may be allowed 10 minutes if previously registered with City Clerk.)

□ CLOSED SESSION:
□ ADJOURNMENT:
ADA POLICY: THE CITY OF MUSKEGON WILL PROVIDE NECESSARY AUXILIARY AIDS AND SERVICES TO INDIVIDUALS
WHO WANT TO ATTEND THE MEETING UPON TWENTY-FOUR HOUR NOTICE TO THE CITY OF MUSKEGON. PLEASE
CONTACT ANN MARIE CUMMINGS, CITY CLERK, 933 TERRACE STREET, MUSKEGON, MI 49440 OR BY CALLING (231)
724-6705 OR TTY/TDD DIAL 7-1-1- TO REQUEST A REPRESENTATIVE TO DIAL (231) 724-6705.
     CITY OF MUSKEGON
       CITY COMMISSION MEETING
                    JANUARY 27, 2015
    CITY COMMISSION CHAMBERS @ 5:30 P.M.
                                MINUTES

The Regular Commission Meeting of the City of Muskegon was held at City Hall,
933 Terrace Street, Muskegon, MI at 5:30 p.m., Tuesday, January 27, 2015.
Mayor Gawron opened the meeting with prayer from Pastor Melvin C. Burns
from the Agape Christian Fellowship Center after which the Commission and
public recited the Pledge of Allegiance to the Flag.
ROLL CALL FOR THE REGULAR COMMISSION MEETING:
Present: Mayor Stephen Gawron, Vice Mayor Lawrence Spataro,
Commissioners Willie German, Dan Rinsema-Sybenga, Byron Turnquist, Ken
Johnson, and Eric Hood, City Manager Franklin Peterson, City Attorney John
Schrier, and City Clerk Ann Marie Cummings.
2015-07 CONSENT AGENDA:
     A. Approval of Minutes. CITY CLERK
SUMMARY OF REQUEST: To approve minutes of the January 12th Commission
Worksession Meeting, and the January 13th City Commission Meeting.
FINANCIAL IMPACT: None.
BUDGET ACTION REQUIRED: None.
STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Approval of the minutes.
     B. MetroPCS First Amendment to the Tower Lease Agreement.         PUBLIC
        WORKS
SUMMARY OF REQUEST: Approve this current staff negotiated amendment to
the contract with MetroPCS and rescind approval of the previous amendment
(2014-86d) on November 10, 2104.
This request is the result of language changes requested by MetroPCS after the
Commission approval on November 10, 2014. The new language changes have
been reviewed and accepted by City staff and by the City Attorney.
FINANCIAL IMPACT: Monthly rental will increase from $1,970.77 per month to
$2,045.77 escalating at the rate of 3% annually for the life of the contract.


                                                                             1
BUDGET ACTION REQUIRED: None.
STAFF RECOMMENDATION: To approve this First Amendment to the 2009 Lease
Agreement and to authorize the Mayor and Clerk to sign.
Motion by Vice Mayor Spataro, second by Commissioner Turnquist to approve
the Consent Agenda minus Item C.
ROLL VOTE: Ayes:      Gawron, Hood, Spataro, German, Rinsema-Sybenga,
           Turnquist, and Johnson
            Nays: None
MOTION PASSES
2015-08 ITEM REMOVED FROM THE CONSENT AGENDA:
      C. Amendment to the Zoning Ordinance.            PLANNING & ECONOMIC
         DEVELOPMENT
SUMMARY OF REQUEST: Request to amend the zoning ordinance to allow
crematories as a special land use permitted in B-4, General Business districts, by
Sytsema Properties, LLC.
FINANCIAL IMPACT: None.
BUDGET ACTION REQUIRED: None.
STAFF RECOMMENDATION: To approve the zoning ordinance amendment.
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION:        The Planning Commission unanimously
recommended approval of the request at their January meeting.
Motion by Commissioner Johnson, second by Commissioner German to amend
the zoning ordinance to allow crematories as a special land use permitted in B-
4, General Business districts.
ROLL VOTE: Ayes: Turnquist, Johnson, Gawron, Hood, Spataro, German, and
           Rinsema-Sybenga
            Nays: None
MOTION PASSES
2015-09 NEW BUSINESS:
      A. Increase Fire Staffing Levels (Fire Fighter). PUBLIC SAFETY
SUMMARY OF REQUEST: The Director of Public Safety requests that the City
Commission review and authorize the increase of fire staffing from the current
level of 30 fire fighters to an authorized strength level of 33. This would allow 11
fire fighters per shift which would compliment our career staff and significantly
reduce our current over-time cost(s).
The department dissolved the part-time fire fighter program in December, 2014,
after noting the impact had no real significant impact on the department as
many of the part-timers (12) were lost to full time departments after basic field


                                                                                   2
training. The part-time fire fighters were costly to equip & train and did not
positively affect the over-time budget as anticipated. Our goal is to replace the
18 authorized part-time staffing levels with 9 careers sometime in the future,
understanding this must be a cost neutral move with the idea of quality over
quantity. The department currently has a hiring list that includes several of the
past part-time fire fighters that received field training at the Muskegon Fire
Department.
FINANCIAL IMPACT: This is a cost neutral program, reallocate the “contract
service” line item into “salaries & benefit” to compensate for the added staffing.
Achieve positive effects on “over-time” line item to offset expenditures now
occurring.
BUDGET ACTION REQUIRED: Reallocate budgeted contract funds – note Union
contract adjustments.
STAFF RECOMMENDATION:            Staff recommends approval of the additional
staffing positions.
Motion by Vice Mayor Spataro, second by Commissioner Johnson to approve
the additional staffing positions as described.
ROLL VOTE: Ayes: Spataro, German, Rinsema-Sybenga, Turnquist, Johnson,
           Gawron, and Hood
            Nays: None
MOTION PASSES
      B. Concurrence with the Housing Board of Appeals Notice and Order to
         Demolish the Following: PUBLIC SAFETY
          1073 Williams Street
          324 W. Larch Avenue
          448 E. Isabella Avenue
          619 Amity Avenue
SUMMARY OF REQUEST: This is to request that the City Commission concur with
the findings of the Housing Board of Appeals that the structures are unsafe,
substandard, a public nuisance and that they be demolished within 30 days or
infraction tickets may be issued. It is further requested that administration be
directed to obtain bids for the demolition of the structures and that the Mayor
and City Clerk be authorized and directed to execute a contract for demolition
with the lowest responsible bidder.
FINANCIAL IMPACT: CDBG funds for 1073 Williams, 324 W. Larch, and 448 E.
Isabella. General funds for 619 Amity.
BUDGET ACTION REQUIRED: None.
STAFF RECOMMENDATION:            To concur with the Housing Board of Appeals



                                                                                 3
decision to demolish.
Motion by Commissioner German, second by Commissioner Rinsema-Sybenga
to concur with the Housing Board Appeals notice and order to demolish 1073
Williams and 448 E. Isabella.
ROLL VOTE: Ayes:    Rinsema-Sybenga, Turnquist, Johnson, Gawron, Hood,
           Spataro, and German
            Nays: None
MOTION PASSES
Motion by Vice Mayor Spataro, second by Commissioner Turnquist to concur
with the Housing Board of Appeals notice and order to demolish 324 W. Larch.
ROLL VOTE: Ayes:    Hood, Spataro, German, Rinsema-Sybenga, Turnquist,
           Johnson, and Gawron
            Nays: None
MOTION PASSES
Motion by Vice Mayor Spataro, second by Commissioner Hood to concur with
the Housing Board of Appeals notice and order to demolish 619 Amity.
Motion by Commissioner Johnson, second by Commissioner Hood to table this
matter for three months.
(Vote on the motion to Table.)
ROLL VOTE: Ayes: German, Johnson, and Hood
            Nays: Rinsema-Sybenga, Turnquist, Gawron, and Spataro
MOTION TO TABLE FAILS
(Vote on the original motion to demolish.)
ROLL VOTE: Ayes: Gawron, Spataro, German, Rinsema-Sybenga, and Turnquist
            Nays: Johnson and Hood
MOTION PASSES
PUBLIC PARTICIPATION: Public comments were received.
ADJOURNMENT: The City Commission Meeting adjourned at 6:40 p.m.


                                             Respectfully submitted,




                                             Ann Marie Cummings, MMC
                                             City Clerk


                                                                           4
        Commission Meeting Date: February 10, 2015

Date:       February 4, 2015
To:         Honorable Mayor & City Commission
From:       Community and Neighborhood Services Dept.
RE:         Purchase of Vacant Land at 2112 Sampson St.


SUMMARY OF REQUEST: To approve the purchase of vacant land
located at 2112 Sampson Street, from Jan Wood for the price of
$23,600 (Twenty-three Thousand, Six Hundred Dollars).
After the sale is completed and 2112 Sampson is obtained, the City
CNS Department will construct a single family dwelling as part of our
HOME funded Homebuyers Program.
FINANCIAL IMPACT: The funding used for the purchase is from 2014
HOME funds.
BUDGET ACTION REQUIRED: None
STAFF RECOMMENDATION: To approve the request to purchase the
property. The purchase price was reached from the recommendation of
the Planning Department’s valuation based on the SEV and assessing
records
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION: None needed
                            AGENDA ITEM NO._____________

                  CITY COMMISSION MEETING ___________________



TO:           Honorable Mayor and City Commission


FROM:         Department of Public Works


DATE:         February 10, 2015


SUBJECT:      2015 Dozer Rental for Beach Leveling


SUMMARY OF REQUEST:
Staff is requesting permission to enter into a rental agreement with Contractors Rental
Corporation, out of Grand Rapids, MI for a John Deere 850K WLT Cab Dozer for leveling sand
at Pere Marquette Beach.


FINANCIAL IMPACT:
Estimated cost for the 2015 Dozer rental is $8,500 (which includes $450 for delivery and
pickup).


BUDGET ACTION REQUIRED:
None.


STAFF RECOMMENDATION:
Approve request.


COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION:
                                                             City of Muskegon




Memo
 To:     Mohammed Al-Shatel
 From:   Doug Sayles
 Date:   2/13/15
 Re:     Dozer Rental for Annual Beach Leveling at PM Park



 Below are 3 bids for the dozer rental, for a maximum of 180 hours usage per month, for
 the Highway Departments’ beach leveling project for 2015.

 Michigan CAT submitted a bid proposal of $9,063 per month plus $900 for delivery and
 pickup for a total of $9,963.

 Southeastern Equipment Co., Inc. submitted a proposal of $8,500 per month including
 delivery and pickup.

 Contractors Rental Corporation submitted a proposal of $8,050 per month plus $450
 for delivery and pickup, for a total of $8,500.

 Based on the availability of the dozer and the tabulated bids above, Contractors Rental
 Corporation, and Southeastern Equipment Co., Inc. are the lowest bidders.

 However based upon the size of the equipment utilized and its ability to get the project
 completed within the allotted rental time of 180 hours and also previously utilizing the
 quoted equipment from Contractors Rental Corporation in 2014, Staff is therefore
 requesting permission to rent the John Deere 850K WLT dozer for leveling the beach
 from Contractors Rental Corporation for 2015.




 1
Date:      February 10, 2015
To:        Honorable Mayor and City Commissioners
From:      Engineering
RE:        KEPS Technologies, Inc. – METRO Act Permit



SUMMARY OF REQUEST: Approve the request for a permit from KEPS
Technologies, Inc. and authorize the Mayor to sign the permit.



FINANCIAL IMPACT: None.



BUDGET ACTION REQUIRED: None.



STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Approve the permit and sign the documents.
                   Commission Meeting Date: February 10, 2015




Date:         January 30, 2015
To:           Honorable Mayor and City Commissioners
From:         Finance Director
RE:           Management Agreement – Fisherman’s Landing



SUMMARY OF REQUEST: Attached is a proposed renewal agreement for
management of Fisherman’s Landing for 2015 - 2019. The general terms of the
agreement are the same as before with the following exceptions:

   •    The proposed agreement covers a period of five years which can be
        terminated by either party with thirty days’ notice to the other party;

   •    A non-disparagement clause was removed.

Staff believes Fisherman’s Landing, Inc. is in the best position to manage the facility
and continue to oversee its’ operation.

FINANCIAL IMPACT:                Approximately $15,000 is received annually for
reimbursement of utility costs plus $7,000 for boat launch permits.

BUDGET ACTION REQUIRED: None at this time.
STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Approval.
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION: None.
                                 Commission Meeting Date: February 10, 2015




Date:            January 30, 2015
To:              Honorable Mayor and City Commissioners
From:            Finance Director
RE:              Banking Services RFP



SUMMARY OF REQUEST: The City recently solicited proposals for banking services. In accordance with
City policy, the three banks having physical locations within the city were invited to participate: Fifth-Third (current
service provider), Huntington, and PNC. Chase Bank also presented a proposal. City staff spent a full day
interviewing the banks and viewing online product service demonstrations. Interviews were conducted prior to
opening price proposals so that staff could evaluate service depth and quality independent of pricing. The RFP
results are summarized as follows:

                                                      Net
                                      Gross        Annualized
                                    Annualized     Cost (after       Financial Strength
                                       Price        earnings       (Bauer Financial Rating
                    Bank             Proposal        credit)           as of 12/2014)

                     Chase           $69,542.35      $20,042.35               4 stars

                   Fifth-Third       $38,678.32       $5,678.32               5 stars

                   Huntington        $56,843.76      $29,343.76               5 stars

                      PNC            $37,808.19      $10,308.19               4 stars




After reviewing proposals and ratings, staff recommends that Fifth-Third Bank be selected to continue providing this
service.

FINANCIAL IMPACT:            Banking services are extremely important to the city. We are heavy users of non-
traditional services such as lockbox remittance processing, ACH disbursements, and other services which are
estimated as equivalent to 2-3 full-time staff positions. Fifth-Third has provided this service to the city for the last
seven years. With this proposal we anticipate that costs will be reduced by approximately 5% from current levels.

BUDGET ACTION REQUIRED: None.
STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Selection of Fifth-Third Bank to provide banking services to the city through
the year 2021.

COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION: None.
        Commission Meeting Date:          February 10, 2015

Date:      January 30, 2015
To:        Honorable Mayor & City Commission
From:      Community and Neighborhood Services Department
RE:        Approval of Sale of City-owned home at 1581 Division


SUMMARY OF REQUEST: To approve the attached resolution and instruct
the Community and Neighborhood Services department to complete the sales
transaction between Shamika L. Ross for the rehabilitated home at 1581
Division, which is part of the City’s HOME Program. Ms. Ross’s purchase
price for the home is $74,900.
FINANCIAL IMPACT: The proceeds from the sale will be used to continue the
rehabilitation of vacant houses through the HOME program to sustain our
current investments to stabilize and revitalize neighborhoods.
BUDGET ACTION REQUIRED: None.
STAFF RECOMMENDATION: To approve the resolution and direct the CNS
staff to complete the sale.
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION: None.
                   MUSKEGON CITY COMMISSION



        RESOLUTION TO APPROVE THE PURCHASE OF
  CURRENTLY CITY-OWNED PROPERTY AT 1581 DIVISION STREET


WHEREAS, the City of Muskegon is dedicated to the redevelopment of its
neighborhoods and;



WHEREAS, the City of Muskegon is dedicated to promoting high quality
affordable single-family housing in the community and;



WHEREAS, the City of Muskegon is dedicated              to   promoting
homeownership throughout its neighborhoods;



NOW THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the City Commission hereby
approves the sale of 1581 Division Street to Shamika L. Ross. Ms. Ross
will purchase the house as an owner-occupied structure.

Adopted this 13th of February, 2015.

Ayes:

Nays:


                          By ______________________________
                             Stephen J. Gawron, Mayor


                          By ______________________________
                             Ann Marie Cummings, MMC City Clerk
AM_Resolution
Date:         February 10, 2015
To:           Honorable Mayor and City Commissioners
From:         Public Safety Director
RE:           Amendment to the Rental Property Ordinance



SUMMARY OF REQUEST: Two small amendments are needed to the recently
adopted Rental Property Ordinance. The requirement for an ID was inadvertently
removed from sec. 10-351(e)(6) and has been added to this version.

Section 10-351(f)(2) states the insurance policy must be on file in the Clerk’s Office
making it more cumbersome on the customer to visit two offices. Under the
proposed language, a copy of the insurance policy can be collected by Safebuilt or
another city designee.



FINANCIAL IMPACT: None.



BUDGET ACTION REQUIRED: None.



STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Approve the Ordinance as presented.
                                      City of Muskegon
                                 Muskegon County, Michigan
                               Ordinance Amendment No. _____


THE CITY OF MUSKEGON HEREBY ORDAINS:


Chapter 10 “Buildings and Building Regulations,” Article VI “Property Maintenance Code,”
Division 2, Subdivision III. “Rental Property” of the Code of Ordinances of the City of
Muskegon is amended as follows:


Subdivision III. Rental Property

Sec. 10-351. Registration of rental dwellings.

(a)    Required. All rental dwellings shall be registered with the city. If the owner does not
       reside within 30 miles of the city, he shall designate a responsible local agent who shall
       be responsible for operating such dwelling in compliance with the law, including this
       article. All official notices may be served on the responsible agent, and any notice so
       served shall be deemed to have been served upon the owner of record. Each owner or
       responsible local agent shall maintain a current list of the number of occupants of each
       rental dwelling for which he is responsible. A rental unit certificate of compliance
       shall not be issued if the registration provisions of this article are not complied with.

(b)    Deadline for registration; failure to comply. All rental dwellings existing as of the
       effective date of the ordinance from which this article is derived shall be registered no
       later than six months after the effective date of this article. The city shall order
       registration prior to that date for any dwelling cited in a notice required by this article.
       Failure to comply with such an order is a violation of this article.

(c)    Registry of new rental dwellings. The owner of a new rental dwelling or of any dwelling
       newly converted to a rental dwelling shall register the rental dwelling prior to allowing
       occupancy of any new rental units.

(d)    Change in register information. The owner of rental dwellings already registered with the
       city or his responsible local agent shall register within 60 days after any change occurs in
       register information. A new owner of a registered dwelling shall register the dwelling
       within 60 days of assuming ownership.

(e)    Application; contents. Application for registration shall be made in such form and in
       accordance with such instructions as may be provided by the administrator and shall
       include:

       (1)     The address of the rental dwelling.
      (2)    The number of dwelling units, the number of rooming units and the number of
             hotel units in the dwelling.

      (3)    The name, residence address, business address, business phone number and
             personal phone number of the owner.

      (4)    The name, residence address, business address, business phone number and
             personal phone number of the manager and responsible local agent designated by
             the owner.

      (5)    The address where the owner or responsible local agent will accept notices or
             orders from the city.

      (6)    The driver’s license or state identification number of the owner or responsible
             local agent and the state in which the license or ID was issued.

(f)   Dwelling fire insurance. In order to protect the health, safety and welfare of the residents
      of the city, it is hereby declared that the city shall require dwelling fire insurance for all
      property owners who let for occupancy premises in the city in the amount and for the
      purposes provided below.

      (1)    Minimum coverage; use of insurance proceeds. All property owners owning
             property in the city shall be required to obtain a minimum of $10,000 in dwelling
             fire insurance. Further, in the event of any fire or loss covered by such insurance,
             it shall be the obligation of the property owner to use such insurance proceeds to
             cause the restoration or demolition or other repair of the property in adherence to
             the city code and all applicable ordinances.

      (2)    Property owners to provide city with insurance information. All property owners
             shall be required to place their insurance company name, policy number and
             policy expiration date on their rental unit registration form, or in the alternative, to
             provide the city with a copy of their actual dwelling fire insurance policy. A
             registration certificate shall not be issued to any person unless the aforementioned
             information has been provided. Violation of this section shall result in suspension
             of a registration certificate. The city shall be informed of any change in policies
             for a particular rental unit or cancellation of a policy for said property within 10
             days of said change or cancellation.

(g)   Inaccurate or incomplete register information. It shall be a violation of this article for an
      owner or a responsible local agent to provide inaccurate information for the register of
      rental dwellings or to fail to provide information required by the city under subsection
      (e) of this section. In those cases in which the owner or responsible local agent is not a
      natural person, the information required for the register shall be provided for the
      organization owning the rental dwelling and for the president, general manager or other
       chief executive officer of the organization. Where more than one natural person has an
       ownership interest, the required information shall be provided for each owner.

(h)    Exemption from registration requirement. Dwellings that are not owner-occupied, but are
       occupied by a grandparent, parent, child or current spouse of the owner are exempt form
       the rental registration requirements outlined in this section. This exemption is limited to
       single family residential dwellings. It is the responsibility of the owner asking to be
       exempted from the rental dwelling registration requirement to provide satisfactory proof
       to the city of the existence of the familial relationship between owner and resident of the
       dwelling.

(Code 1975, § 4-82; Or. No. 2304, 2-28-12)


This ordinance adopted:


       Ayes: ______________________________________________________________
       Nays: _______________________________________________________________


Adoption Date: _________________________
Effective Date: _________________________
First Reading: _________________________
Second Reading: ________________________



                                                    CITY OF MUSKEGON


                                                    By ______________________________
                                                       Ann Cummings, MMC
                                                       City Clerk
                                        CERTIFICATE

      The undersigned, being the duly qualified clerk of the City of Muskegon, Muskegon
County, Michigan, does hereby certify that the foregoing is a true and complete copy of an
ordinance adopted by the City Commission of the City of Muskegon, at a regular meeting of the
City Commission on the          day of                      , 2015, at which meeting a quorum
was present and remained throughout, and that the original of said ordinance is on file in the
records of the City of Muskegon. I further certify that the meeting was conducted, and public
notice was given, pursuant to and in full compliance with Act No. 267, Public Acts of Michigan
of 1976, as amended, and that minutes were kept and will be or have been made available as
required thereby.


DATED:                    , 2015


                                       _______________________________________
                                       Ann Cummings, MMC
                                       Clerk, City of Muskegon

Publish:     Notice of Adoption to be published once within ten (10) days of final adoption.
Date:            February 10, 2015
To:              Honorable Mayor and City Commissioners
From:            Engineering
RE:             Consideration of Bids for:
                Muskegon/Webster Avenues from 9th to Spring
                (H-1693; S-672; W-747)


SUMMARY OF REQUEST:
Award the reconstruction contract, using base bid, for Muskegon & Webster Avenues from
ninth to Spring to Jackson Merkey Contractors out of Muskegon TWP since they were the
lowest responsible bidder with a total bid price of $4,367,400.55 (see attached bid
tabulation).

Furthermore, it is kindly requested that staff be authorized to remove and/or adjust
quantities regarding landscape and stamped crosswalks to meet budget constraints.


FINANCIAL IMPACT:
The construction cost of $4,367,400.55.


BUDGET ACTION REQUIRED:
None at this time, however, future reforecast/budgets might have to be adjusted.


STAFF RECOMMENDATION:
Award the contract to Jackson Merkey and authorize staff to make the necessary adjustments
as per the summary of request.



COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION:



C:\Users\ann.cummings\AppData\Local\Microsoft\Windows\Temporary Internet Files\Content.Outlook\147TECTR\CONAWA 2-
10-15.doc
         3355 Evergreen Dr. NE Grand Rapids, MI 49525
         t. (616) 364-8491 f. (616) 364-6955
                                                                                                                                                                           Bid Tabulation

Owner:                                                                                          1st                              2nd                                            3rd
  City of Muskegon
Project Title:                                                                                    Jackson-Merkey Contractors           McCormick Sand, Inc.                           Brenner Excavating, Inc.
  Webster Avenue & Muskegon Avenue Street Reconstruction and Utility Improvements                      3430 Lund Avenue                 5430 Russell Road                               2841 132nd Avenue
Bid Date & Time:                                                    Project #:                       Muskegon, MI 49442                Twin Lake, MI 49457                              Hopkins, MI 49328
  January 27, 2015 at 2:00 PM                                         2140401


Item No.                           Description                          Quantity      Unit        Unit Price      Total Amount     Unit Price           Total Amount               Unit Price           Total Amount

           Miscellaneous Project Items

    1      Mobilization, Max. $300,000                                     1           LS       $183,000.00       $183,000.00    $300,000.00            $300,000.00              $291,121.25            $291,121.25

    2      Maintaining Traffic                                             1           LS         $35,000.00       $35,000.00    $191,750.00            $191,750.00                $58,560.00             $58,560.00

    3      Sign, Rem                                                       1           LS             $1,500.00     $1,500.00       $1,600.00               $1,600.00                 $1,615.00             $1,615.00

    4      Maintenance Gravel                                            1,000        Ton                $9.75      $9,750.00            $12.00           $12,000.00                     $13.70           $13,700.00

    5      Hand Patching                                                  50          Ton              $200.00     $10,000.00          $200.00            $10,000.00                   $215.50            $10,775.00

    6      Non Haz Contaminated Material Handling and Disposal, L         500         Cyd               $10.00      $5,000.00            $40.00           $20,000.00                     $64.00           $32,000.00

    7      Subgrade Undercutting, Type II                                2,500        Cyd                $6.00     $15,000.00            $10.00           $25,000.00                     $15.20           $38,000.00

    8      Subgrade Proof-Rolling                                        2,000        Syd                $0.20        $400.00              $0.25              $500.00                      $0.62            $1,240.00

    9      High Strength Geogrid                                         2,000        Syd                $6.00     $12,000.00              $5.00          $10,000.00                       $5.85          $11,700.00

   10      Underdrain, Subgrade, 6 inch                                  1,000         Ft                $5.50      $5,500.00              $5.00            $5,000.00                      $3.65            $3,650.00

   11      Erosion Control, Silt Fence                                    200          Ft                $2.00        $400.00              $2.00              $400.00                      $1.95               $390.00

   12      Erosion Control, Inlet Protection, Fabric Drop                 200          Ea              $100.00     $20,000.00            $75.00           $15,000.00                     $83.90           $16,780.00

                                                        Miscellaneous Project Items Subtotal:                     $297,550.00                           $591,250.00                                     $479,531.25


           Pavement Marking & Signing                                      0

   13      Pavt Mrkg, Polyurea, 4 inch, White                            3,285         Ft                $0.45      $1,478.25              $0.45            $1,478.25                      $0.48            $1,576.80

   14      Pavt Mrkg, Polyurea, 4 inch, Yellow                          19,895         Ft                $0.45      $8,952.75              $0.45            $8,952.75                      $0.48            $9,549.60

   15      Pavt Mrkg, Polyurea, 12 inch Cross Hatching, White             860          Ft                $4.15      $3,569.00              $4.15            $3,569.00                      $4.45            $3,827.00

   16      Pavt Mrkg, Polyurea, 12 inch Cross Hatching, Yellow            110          Ft                $4.15        $456.50              $4.15              $456.50                      $4.45               $489.50

   17      Pavt Mrkg, Polyurea, 24 inch, Stop Bar                        1,415         Ft                $9.00     $12,735.00              $9.00          $12,735.00                       $9.70          $13,725.50

   18      Pavt Mrkg, Polyurea, 6 inch, Crosswalk                        8,350         Ft                $2.25     $18,787.50              $2.25          $18,787.50                       $2.40          $20,040.00

   19      Pavt Mrkg, Polyurea, Lt Turn Arrow Sym                         12           Ea              $115.00      $1,380.00          $115.00              $1,380.00                  $124.00              $1,488.00

   20      Pavt Mrkg, Polyurea, Rt Turn Arrow Sym                          1           Ea              $115.00        $115.00          $115.00                $115.00                  $124.00                 $124.00

   21      Pavt Mrkg, Polyurea, Thru Arrow Sym                             1           Ea              $105.00        $105.00          $105.00                $105.00                  $113.00                 $113.00

   22      Pavt Mrkg, Polyurea, Only                                      14           Ea              $125.00      $1,750.00          $125.00              $1,750.00                  $134.50              $1,883.00

   23      Pavt Mrkg, Polyurea, Sharrow, Symbol                           96           Ea              $140.00     $13,440.00          $140.00            $13,440.00                   $150.50            $14,448.00




         page 1 of 24                                                                                                            S:\2014\2140401 City of Muskegon\CDS\bid tab 2014-01-27 Muskegon & Webster Ave.xlsx
         3355 Evergreen Dr. NE Grand Rapids, MI 49525
         t. (616) 364-8491 f. (616) 364-6955
                                                                                                                                                                       Bid Tabulation

Owner:                                                                                      1st                              2nd                                            3rd
  City of Muskegon
Project Title:                                                                                Jackson-Merkey Contractors           McCormick Sand, Inc.                           Brenner Excavating, Inc.
  Webster Avenue & Muskegon Avenue Street Reconstruction and Utility Improvements                  3430 Lund Avenue                 5430 Russell Road                               2841 132nd Avenue
Bid Date & Time:                                                  Project #:                     Muskegon, MI 49442                Twin Lake, MI 49457                              Hopkins, MI 49328
  January 27, 2015 at 2:00 PM                                       2140401


Item No.                            Description                      Quantity     Unit        Unit Price      Total Amount     Unit Price           Total Amount               Unit Price           Total Amount

   24      Sign, Type III, Erect, Salv                                   7         Ea               $25.00        $175.00            $25.00               $175.00                    $26.90                $188.30

   25      Sign, Type IIIA                                              472        Sft              $16.50      $7,788.00            $16.50             $7,788.00                    $17.80             $8,401.60

   26      Sign, Type IIIB                                              197        Sft              $13.50      $2,659.50            $13.50             $2,659.50                    $14.50             $2,856.50

   27      Post, Steel, 3 lb                                           2,531       Ft                $3.95      $9,997.45              $3.95            $9,997.45                      $4.25          $10,756.75

   28      Reflective Panel for Permanent Sign Support, 6 foot          37         Ea               $30.00      $1,110.00            $30.00             $1,110.00                    $32.30             $1,195.10

   29      Post Hole Through Conc for Steel Post                        25         Ea               $30.00        $750.00            $25.00               $625.00                    $32.30                $807.50

                                                     Pavement Marking & Signing Subtotal:                      $85,248.95                             $85,123.95                                      $91,470.15


           Roadway Reconstruction

   30      Dr Structure, Rem                                            69         Ea              $340.00     $23,460.00          $400.00            $27,600.00                   $247.00            $17,043.00

   31      Dr Structure, Abandon                                         1         Ea              $235.00        $235.00          $400.00                $400.00                  $247.00                 $247.00

   32      Flowable Fill, Non-Structural                                10        Cyd              $190.00      $1,900.00          $290.00              $2,900.00                  $139.00              $1,390.00

   33      Sewer, Rem, Less than 24 inch                               2,515       Ft                $7.00     $17,605.00              $7.00          $17,605.00                       $6.55          $16,473.25

   34      Sewer, Rem, 24 inch to 48 inch                               390        Ft                $9.00      $3,510.00              $9.00            $3,510.00                      $8.15            $3,178.50

   35      Stump, Rem, 37 inch or Larger                                 1         Ea              $260.00        $260.00          $300.00                $300.00                 $1,066.00             $1,066.00

   36      Sewer Bulkhead, 12 inch                                       2         Ea              $260.00        $520.00          $100.00                $200.00                  $361.00                 $722.00

   37      Pavt, Rem, Special                                           110        Sta            $4,250.00   $467,500.00       $1,750.00           $192,500.00                   $2,991.00         $329,010.00

   38      Cold Milling HMA Surface                                     925        Syd               $3.00      $2,775.00              $2.00            $1,850.00                      $4.05            $3,746.25

   39      Embankment, CIP                                             6,175      Cyd                $9.00     $55,575.00              $4.00          $24,700.00                       $5.80          $35,815.00

   40      Excavation, Earth                                          29,525      Cyd                $0.10      $2,952.50              $1.50          $44,287.50                       $3.65        $107,766.25

   41      Subbase, CIP                                               17,700      Cyd                $0.10      $1,770.00              $5.50          $97,350.00                       $5.70        $100,890.00

   42      Aggregate Base, 8 inch                                     50,530       Syd               $5.50    $277,915.00              $6.50        $328,445.00                        $6.30        $318,339.00

   43      Dr Structure, 48 inch dia                                    69         Ea             $1,490.00   $102,810.00       $1,600.00           $110,400.00                   $1,280.00           $88,320.00

   44      Dr Structure, 60 inch dia                                     5         Ea             $2,600.00    $13,000.00       $3,500.00             $17,500.00                  $2,716.00           $13,580.00

   45      Dr Structure, 72 inch dia                                     1         Ea             $3,175.00     $3,175.00       $3,700.00               $3,700.00                 $3,831.00             $3,831.00

   46      Dr Structure Cover, Type B                                   79         Ea              $325.00     $25,675.00          $350.00            $27,650.00                   $601.50            $47,518.50

   47      Dr Structure Cover, Type K                                   100        Ea              $500.00     $50,000.00          $500.00            $50,000.00                   $771.00            $77,100.00




         page 2 of 24                                                                                                        S:\2014\2140401 City of Muskegon\CDS\bid tab 2014-01-27 Muskegon & Webster Ave.xlsx
         3355 Evergreen Dr. NE Grand Rapids, MI 49525
         t. (616) 364-8491 f. (616) 364-6955
                                                                                                                                                             Bid Tabulation

Owner:                                                                              1st                            2nd                                            3rd
  City of Muskegon
Project Title:                                                                        Jackson-Merkey Contractors         McCormick Sand, Inc.                           Brenner Excavating, Inc.
  Webster Avenue & Muskegon Avenue Street Reconstruction and Utility Improvements          3430 Lund Avenue               5430 Russell Road                               2841 132nd Avenue
Bid Date & Time:                                             Project #:                  Muskegon, MI 49442              Twin Lake, MI 49457                              Hopkins, MI 49328
  January 27, 2015 at 2:00 PM                                  2140401


Item No.                          Description                   Quantity     Unit     Unit Price    Total Amount     Unit Price           Total Amount               Unit Price           Total Amount

   48      Dr Structure Cover, Type D                               2         Ea          $450.00       $900.00          $420.00                $840.00                  $713.50              $1,427.00

   49      Dr Structure Cover, Type G                               2         Ea          $280.00       $560.00          $265.00                $530.00                  $548.50              $1,097.00

   50      Dr Structure Cover, Type Q, Modified                    27         Ea          $350.00     $9,450.00          $375.00            $10,125.00                   $621.00            $16,767.00

   51      Dr Structure Cover, Adj, Case 1                         146        Ea          $375.00    $54,750.00          $450.00            $65,700.00                   $412.50            $60,225.00

   52      Dr Structure Cover, Adj, Case 2                         13         Ea          $320.00     $4,160.00          $250.00              $3,250.00                  $412.50              $5,362.50

   53      Dr Structure, Tap, 12 inch                               8         Ea          $295.00     $2,360.00          $250.00              $2,000.00                  $120.50                 $964.00

   54      Dr Structure, Tap, 30 inch                               2         Ea          $615.00     $1,230.00          $550.00              $1,100.00                  $397.50                 $795.00

   55      Sewer, Cl E, 12 inch, Tr Det B                         1,796       Ft           $33.00    $59,268.00            $40.00           $71,840.00                     $28.40           $51,006.40

   56      Sewer, Cl E, 30 inch, Tr Det B                          331        Ft           $61.00    $20,191.00            $75.00           $24,825.00                     $65.70           $21,746.70

   57      Sewer, Cl A, 6 inch, Tr Det B                           10         Ft           $24.00       $240.00            $25.00               $250.00                    $52.10                $521.00

   58      Sewer, Cl A, 12 inch, Tr Det B                          253        Ft           $28.00     $7,084.00            $40.00           $10,120.00                     $25.10             $6,350.30

   59      Sewer, Cl A, 24 inch, Tr Det B                          24         Ft          $100.00     $2,400.00            $69.00             $1,656.00                    $59.30             $1,423.20

   60      Sewer, Cl A, 30 inch, Tr Det B                          16         Ft           $85.00     $1,360.00            $75.00             $1,200.00                    $75.20             $1,203.20

   61      Paved Ditch, HMA                                        20         Syd          $50.00     $1,000.00            $60.00             $1,200.00                    $53.80             $1,076.00

   62      Shoulder Gutter, Conc, Det 2                             1         Ea          $450.00       $450.00          $450.00                $450.00                  $430.50                 $430.50

   63      Spillway, Conc                                           7         Ft           $56.00       $392.00            $63.00               $441.00                    $58.60                $410.20

   64      HMA, 4E1                                               6,625      Ton           $78.50   $520,062.50            $78.48         $519,930.00                      $84.50         $559,812.50

   65      HMA, 3E1                                               7,790      Ton           $73.80   $574,902.00            $73.79         $574,824.10                      $79.40         $618,526.00

   66      Textured Asphalt Crosswalk                            24,715       Sft           $6.75   $166,826.25              $5.30        $130,989.50                        $5.70        $140,875.50

   67      Driveway, Nonreinf Conc, 6 inch                        1,009       Syd          $29.00    $29,261.00            $32.00           $32,288.00                     $31.40           $31,682.60

   68      Curb and Gutter, Conc, Det F4, Modified               22,034       Ft           $11.50   $253,391.00            $10.50         $231,357.00                      $11.70         $257,797.80

   69      Curb, Conc, Det E4                                      332        Ft           $24.50     $8,134.00            $26.00             $8,632.00                    $26.00             $8,632.00

   70      Driveway Opening, Conc, Det M                          1,666       Ft           $16.00    $26,656.00            $17.00           $28,322.00                     $16.40           $27,322.40

   71      Fence, Moving                                           136        Ft           $20.00     $2,720.00            $25.00             $3,400.00                    $15.70             $2,135.20

   72      Riprap, Plain                                           10         Syd          $75.00       $750.00            $70.00               $700.00                    $37.40                $374.00

   73      Slope Restoration                                     18,315       Syd           $4.75    $86,996.25              $5.00          $91,575.00                       $2.60          $47,619.00




         page 3 of 24                                                                                              S:\2014\2140401 City of Muskegon\CDS\bid tab 2014-01-27 Muskegon & Webster Ave.xlsx
         3355 Evergreen Dr. NE Grand Rapids, MI 49525
         t. (616) 364-8491 f. (616) 364-6955
                                                                                                                                                                         Bid Tabulation

Owner:                                                                                       1st                               2nd                                            3rd
  City of Muskegon
Project Title:                                                                                 Jackson-Merkey Contractors            McCormick Sand, Inc.                           Brenner Excavating, Inc.
  Webster Avenue & Muskegon Avenue Street Reconstruction and Utility Improvements                   3430 Lund Avenue                  5430 Russell Road                               2841 132nd Avenue
Bid Date & Time:                                                  Project #:                      Muskegon, MI 49442                 Twin Lake, MI 49457                              Hopkins, MI 49328
  January 27, 2015 at 2:00 PM                                       2140401


Item No.                            Description                      Quantity      Unit        Unit Price       Total Amount     Unit Price           Total Amount               Unit Price           Total Amount

                                                         Roadway Reconstruction Subtotal:                      $2,886,131.50                       $2,768,442.10                                   $3,031,617.75


           Sidewalk

   74      Sidewalk, Rem                                               6,056       Syd                $5.85      $35,427.60              $8.00          $48,448.00                       $5.75          $34,822.00

   75      Sidewalk, Conc, 4 inch                                     40,130        Sft               $2.75     $110,357.50              $3.15        $126,409.50                        $2.90        $116,377.00

   76      Sidewalk, Conc, 6 inch                                      4,560        Sft               $3.25      $14,820.00              $3.65          $16,644.00                       $3.50          $15,960.00

   77      Sidewalk Ramp, Conc, 6 inch                                 9,215        Sft               $4.75      $43,771.25              $5.40          $49,761.00                       $5.00          $46,075.00

   78      Detectable Warning Surface                                  1,422        Ft               $32.00      $45,504.00            $32.00           $45,504.00                     $34.40           $48,916.80

                                                                        Sidewalk Subtotal:                      $249,880.35                           $286,766.50                                     $262,150.80


           Sanitary Sewer

   79      San Sewer, Rem, 6 inch                                       60          Ft                $6.50         $390.00              $5.00              $300.00                      $8.15               $489.00

   80      San Sewer, Rem, 8 inch                                       80          Ft                $6.50         $520.00              $5.00              $400.00                      $8.15               $652.00

   81      Abandon Well in Sanitary Manhole                              1          Ea             $1,500.00      $1,500.00       $1,000.00               $1,000.00                 $2,133.00             $2,133.00

   82      Cap Existing DI Sanitary Cleanout Riser                       1          Ea              $625.00         $625.00          $400.00                $400.00                  $426.00                 $426.00

   83      Sanitary Manhole, 48 inch dia                                 3          Ea             $2,900.00      $8,700.00       $4,500.00             $13,500.00                  $4,376.00           $13,128.00

   84      San Sewer, 6 inch, Tr Det B                                  63          Ft               $81.00       $5,103.00            $40.00             $2,520.00                    $72.50             $4,567.50

   85      San Sewer, 8 inch, Tr Det B                                  80          Ft               $69.25       $5,540.00            $50.00             $4,000.00                    $73.50             $5,880.00

   86      San Sewer, Connect to 8 inch                                 10          Ea              $150.00       $1,500.00          $500.00              $5,000.00                  $261.00              $2,610.00

                                                                  Sanitary Sewer Subtotal:                       $23,878.00                             $27,120.00                                      $29,885.50


           Water Main

   87      Hydrant, Rem                                                 16          Ea             $2,656.00     $42,496.00          $500.00              $8,000.00                  $535.00              $8,560.00

   88      Hydrant, Adj                                                  2          Ea              $750.00       $1,500.00          $750.00              $1,500.00                  $698.50              $1,397.00

   89      Water Main, Valve and Box, 6 inch, Rem                        1          Ea              $350.00         $350.00          $250.00                $250.00                  $535.00                 $535.00

   90      Water Main, Valve and Box, 8 inch, Rem                        1          Ea              $350.00         $350.00          $250.00                $250.00                  $535.00                 $535.00

   91      Water Main, Valve and Manhole, 16 inch, Rem                   4          Ea              $850.00       $3,400.00       $1,000.00               $4,000.00                 $1,029.00             $4,116.00

   92      Water Main, Valve and Manhole, 20 inch, Rem                   1          Ea              $850.00         $850.00       $1,000.00               $1,000.00                 $1,029.00             $1,029.00

   93      Water Main, Valve Manhole, Rem                                1          Ea              $500.00         $500.00          $400.00                $400.00                  $494.00                 $494.00




         page 4 of 24                                                                                                          S:\2014\2140401 City of Muskegon\CDS\bid tab 2014-01-27 Muskegon & Webster Ave.xlsx
         3355 Evergreen Dr. NE Grand Rapids, MI 49525
         t. (616) 364-8491 f. (616) 364-6955
                                                                                                                                                               Bid Tabulation

Owner:                                                                              1st                              2nd                                            3rd
  City of Muskegon
Project Title:                                                                        Jackson-Merkey Contractors           McCormick Sand, Inc.                           Brenner Excavating, Inc.
  Webster Avenue & Muskegon Avenue Street Reconstruction and Utility Improvements          3430 Lund Avenue                 5430 Russell Road                               2841 132nd Avenue
Bid Date & Time:                                             Project #:                  Muskegon, MI 49442                Twin Lake, MI 49457                              Hopkins, MI 49328
  January 27, 2015 at 2:00 PM                                  2140401


Item No.                         Description                    Quantity     Unit     Unit Price      Total Amount     Unit Price           Total Amount               Unit Price           Total Amount

   94      Water Main, Abandoned Valve Box, Rem                    33         Ea           $130.00      $4,290.00            $50.00             $1,650.00                  $193.00              $6,369.00

   95      Water Main, Plug, 4 inch                                 1         Ea           $585.00        $585.00          $300.00                $300.00                  $312.00                 $312.00

   96      Water Main, Plug, 6 inch                                 7         Ea           $615.00      $4,305.00            $50.00               $350.00                  $345.00              $2,415.00

   97      Water Main, Plug, 8 inch                                 1         Ea           $650.00        $650.00          $300.00                $300.00                  $417.00                 $417.00

   98      Water Main, Cap, 4 inch                                  1         Ea           $715.00        $715.00          $300.00                $300.00                  $359.50                 $359.50

   99      Water Main, Cap, 6 inch                                  6         Ea           $735.00      $4,410.00            $50.00               $300.00                  $377.00              $2,262.00

  100      Water Main, Cap or Plug, 6 inch                         26         Ea           $735.00     $19,110.00            $50.00             $1,300.00                  $345.00              $8,970.00

  101      Water Main, Cap or Plug, 8 inch                          3         Ea           $785.00      $2,355.00          $300.00                $900.00                  $417.00              $1,251.00

  102      Water Main, Temporary Cap, 6 inch                        7         Ea           $735.00      $5,145.00            $50.00               $350.00                  $321.50              $2,250.50

  103      Water Main, Valve Box, Adj                              37         Ea           $200.00      $7,400.00          $450.00            $16,650.00                   $332.00            $12,284.00

  104      Water Main, Meter Box, Adj                               1         Ea           $200.00        $200.00          $500.00                $500.00                  $332.00                 $332.00

  105      Water Main, DI, 4 inch, Tr Det G                        61         Ft            $71.00      $4,331.00            $54.00             $3,294.00                    $54.20             $3,306.20

  106      Water Main, DI, 6 inch, Tr Det G                        191        Ft            $71.00     $13,561.00            $58.00           $11,078.00                     $44.20             $8,442.20

  107      Water Main, DI, 8 inch, Tr Det G                       5,264       Ft            $41.00    $215,824.00            $40.00         $210,560.00                      $45.10         $237,406.40

  108      Water Main, DI, 16 inch, Tr Det G                       30         Ft           $215.00      $6,450.00            $95.00             $2,850.00                  $160.00              $4,800.00

  109      Water Main, DI, 20 inch, Tr Det G                       10         Ft           $200.00      $2,000.00          $140.00              $1,400.00                  $187.00              $1,870.00

  110      Water Main, Valve and Box, 4 inch                        2         Ea           $950.00      $1,900.00          $600.00              $1,200.00                 $1,043.00             $2,086.00

  111      Water Main, Valve and Box, 6 inch                        9         Ea          $1,080.00     $9,720.00       $1,250.00             $11,250.00                  $1,192.00           $10,728.00

  112      Water Main, Valve and Box, 8 inch                       18         Ea          $1,400.00    $25,200.00       $2,250.00             $40,500.00                  $1,560.00           $28,080.00

  113      Water Main, Valve and Box, 16 inch                       4         Ea          $6,675.00    $26,700.00       $6,800.00             $27,200.00                  $7,211.00           $28,844.00

  114      Water Main, 11 1/4 Degree Bend, 8 inch                   1         Ea           $375.00        $375.00          $350.00                $350.00                  $521.00                 $521.00

  115      Water Main, 45 Degree Bend, 8 inch                      37         Ea           $395.00     $14,615.00          $650.00            $24,050.00                   $535.00            $19,795.00

  116      Water Main, Tee, 8 inch x 8 inch x 6 inch               10         Ea           $560.00      $5,600.00          $750.00              $7,500.00                  $796.50              $7,965.00

  117      Water Main, Tee, 8 inch x 8 inch x 8 inch                1         Ea           $715.00        $715.00          $825.00                $825.00                  $849.50                 $849.50

  118      Water Main, Cross, 8 inch x 8 inch                       3         Ea          $1,000.00     $3,000.00       $1,500.00               $4,500.00                 $1,318.00             $3,954.00

  119      Water Main, Cross, 16 inch x 8 inch                      1         Ea          $2,300.00     $2,300.00       $3,000.00               $3,000.00                 $2,782.00             $2,782.00




         page 5 of 24                                                                                                S:\2014\2140401 City of Muskegon\CDS\bid tab 2014-01-27 Muskegon & Webster Ave.xlsx
         3355 Evergreen Dr. NE Grand Rapids, MI 49525
         t. (616) 364-8491 f. (616) 364-6955
                                                                                                                                                                             Bid Tabulation

Owner:                                                                                            1st                              2nd                                            3rd
  City of Muskegon
Project Title:                                                                                      Jackson-Merkey Contractors           McCormick Sand, Inc.                           Brenner Excavating, Inc.
  Webster Avenue & Muskegon Avenue Street Reconstruction and Utility Improvements                        3430 Lund Avenue                 5430 Russell Road                               2841 132nd Avenue
Bid Date & Time:                                                        Project #:                     Muskegon, MI 49442                Twin Lake, MI 49457                              Hopkins, MI 49328
  January 27, 2015 at 2:00 PM                                             2140401


Item No.                           Description                             Quantity     Unit        Unit Price      Total Amount     Unit Price           Total Amount               Unit Price           Total Amount

  120      Water Main, Sleeve, 4 inch                                          2         Ea              $875.00      $1,750.00       $1,400.00               $2,800.00                  $739.50              $1,479.00

  121      Water Main, Sleeve, 6 inch                                          1         Ea              $960.00        $960.00       $2,400.00               $2,400.00                  $800.50                 $800.50

  122      Water Main, Sleeve, 8 inch                                         13         Ea             $1,165.00    $15,145.00       $1,800.00             $23,400.00                   $827.00            $10,751.00

  123      Water Main, Sleeve, 16 inch                                         8         Ea             $3,750.00    $30,000.00       $3,000.00             $24,000.00                  $2,240.00           $17,920.00

  124      Water Main, Sleeve, 20 inch                                         2         Ea             $2,685.00     $5,370.00       $3,600.00               $7,200.00                 $2,937.00             $5,874.00

  125      Water Main, Reducer, 8 inch x 6 inch                               11         Ea              $350.00      $3,850.00          $475.00              $5,225.00                  $498.00              $5,478.00

  126      Water Main, Tapping Tee and Valve, 16 inch x 16 inch x              4         Ea             $4,300.00    $17,200.00       $4,000.00             $16,000.00                  $3,325.00           $13,300.00

  127      Water Main, Tapping Tee and Valve, 20 inch x 20 inch x 4            2         Ea             $3,650.00     $7,300.00       $3,300.00               $6,600.00                 $2,975.00             $5,950.00

  128      Water Main, Tapping Tee and Valve, 20 inch x 20 inch x 6            3         Ea             $3,950.00    $11,850.00       $4,100.00             $12,300.00                  $3,219.00             $9,657.00

  129      Fire Hydrant                                                       12         Ea             $2,485.00    $29,820.00       $2,800.00             $33,600.00                  $3,063.00           $36,756.00

  130      Investigate Location, Material, and Size of Existing Water         53         Ea              $350.00     $18,550.00          $175.00              $9,275.00                  $303.50            $16,085.50

  131      Water Service, Remove and Plug Existing Tap                         0         Ea              $350.00          $0.00                                     $0.00                                           $0.00

  132      Water Service, 1 inch                                             3,175       Ft               $16.50     $52,387.50            $15.00           $47,625.00                     $19.40           $61,595.00

  133      Water Service, 2 inch                                              731        Ft               $27.75     $20,285.25            $22.00           $16,082.00                     $26.50           $19,371.50

  134      Water Service, Corporation Stop, 1 inch                            95         Ea              $322.00     $30,590.00          $400.00            $38,000.00                   $197.50            $18,762.50

  135      Water Service, Corporation Stop, 2 inch                            22         Ea              $715.00     $15,730.00          $650.00            $14,300.00                   $615.50            $13,541.00

  136      Water Service, Curb Stop and Box, 1 inch                           95         Ea              $420.00     $39,900.00          $500.00            $47,500.00                   $313.00            $29,735.00

  137      Water Service, Curb Stop and Box, 2 inch                           22         Ea              $670.00     $14,740.00          $600.00            $13,200.00                   $656.00            $14,432.00

                                                                           Water Main Subtotal:                     $746,329.75                           $707,364.00                                     $696,805.30


           Landscaping

  138      Acer freemani 'Celzam', 2 1/2" cal.                                 9         Ea              $400.00      $3,600.00          $375.00              $3,375.00                  $403.50              $3,631.50

  139      Acer freemani 'Jeffersred', 2 1/2" cal.                            14         Ea              $400.00      $5,600.00          $375.00              $5,250.00                  $403.50              $5,649.00

  140      Acer platanoides 'Crimson King', 2 1/2" cal.                       13         Ea              $325.00      $4,225.00          $325.00              $4,225.00                  $350.00              $4,550.00

  141      Acer rubrum 'Franksred', 2 1/2" cal.                                8         Ea              $400.00      $3,200.00          $385.00              $3,080.00                  $414.50              $3,316.00

  142      Celtis occidentalis 'All Seasons', 2 1/2" cal.                     12         Ea              $325.00      $3,900.00          $400.00              $4,800.00                  $430.50              $5,166.00

  143      Ginko biloba 'Autumn Gold', 2 1/2" cal.                            16         Ea              $525.00      $8,400.00          $355.00              $5,680.00                  $382.00              $6,112.00




         page 6 of 24                                                                                                              S:\2014\2140401 City of Muskegon\CDS\bid tab 2014-01-27 Muskegon & Webster Ave.xlsx
         3355 Evergreen Dr. NE Grand Rapids, MI 49525
         t. (616) 364-8491 f. (616) 364-6955
                                                                                                                                                                             Bid Tabulation

Owner:                                                                                             1st                             2nd                                            3rd
  City of Muskegon
Project Title:                                                                                       Jackson-Merkey Contractors          McCormick Sand, Inc.                           Brenner Excavating, Inc.
  Webster Avenue & Muskegon Avenue Street Reconstruction and Utility Improvements                         3430 Lund Avenue                5430 Russell Road                               2841 132nd Avenue
Bid Date & Time:                                                         Project #:                     Muskegon, MI 49442               Twin Lake, MI 49457                              Hopkins, MI 49328
  January 27, 2015 at 2:00 PM                                              2140401


Item No.                             Description                            Quantity      Unit       Unit Price     Total Amount     Unit Price           Total Amount               Unit Price           Total Amount

  144      Gleditsia t.i. 'Skyline', 2 1/2" cal.                               15         Ea             $320.00      $4,800.00          $275.00              $4,125.00                  $296.00              $4,440.00

  145      Phellodendron amurensis Macho, 2 1/2" cal.                           4         Ea             $450.00      $1,800.00          $355.00              $1,420.00                  $382.00              $1,528.00

  146      Platanus x acerfolia 'Morton Circle Exclamation', 2 1/2" ca         16         Ea             $325.00      $5,200.00          $333.00              $5,328.00                  $358.50              $5,736.00

  147      Pyrus calleryana 'Cleveland select', 2 1/2" cal.                    20         Ea             $300.00      $6,000.00          $285.00              $5,700.00                  $307.00              $6,140.00

  148      Quercus robur 'Fastigiata', 2 1/2" cal.                              3         Ea             $410.00      $1,230.00          $380.00              $1,140.00                  $409.00              $1,227.00

  149      Quercus rubra, 2 1/2" cal.                                           9         Ea             $375.00      $3,375.00          $340.00              $3,060.00                  $366.00              $3,294.00

  150      Syringa reticulata Ivory Silk, 2 1/2" cal.                          10         Ea             $325.00      $3,250.00          $282.00              $2,820.00                  $303.50              $3,035.00

  151      Tilia cordata 'Corzam', 2 1/2" cal.                                  5         Ea             $410.00      $2,050.00          $335.00              $1,675.00                  $360.50              $1,802.50

  152      Ulmus x. Accolade, 2 1/2" cal.                                      20         Ea             $325.00      $6,500.00          $317.00              $6,340.00                  $341.00              $6,820.00

  153      Zelkova serrata 'Green Vase', 2 1/2" cal.                           18         Ea             $410.00      $7,380.00          $335.00              $6,030.00                  $360.50              $6,489.00

  154      Tree Gator Bags, Supply, Install and Fill                           192        Ea              $41.00      $7,872.00            $20.00             $3,840.00                    $21.50             $4,128.00

                                                                           Landscaping Subtotal:                     $78,382.00                             $67,888.00                                      $73,064.00


                                                                                       Total Bid                   $4,367,400.55                       $4,533,954.55                                   $4,664,524.75

           Alternate Bid Items

  155      Aggregate Base, 8 inch, 21AA                                      50,530       Syd              $6.20    $313,286.00            $10.80         $545,724.00                        $8.95        $452,243.50

  156      Acer freemani 'Celzam', 2" to 2 1/2" cal.                            9         Ea             $365.00      $3,285.00          $275.00              $2,475.00                  $296.00              $2,664.00

  157      Acer freemani 'Jeffersred', 2" to 2 1/2" cal.                       14         Ea             $365.00      $5,110.00          $325.00              $4,550.00                  $350.00              $4,900.00

  158      Acer platanoides 'Crimson King', 2" to 2 1/2" cal.                  13         Ea             $325.00      $4,225.00          $295.00              $3,835.00                  $317.50              $4,127.50

  159      Acer rubrum 'Franksred', 2" to 2 1/2" cal.                           8         Ea             $345.00      $2,760.00          $335.00              $2,680.00                  $360.50              $2,884.00

  160      Celtis occidentalis 'All Seasons', 2" to 2 1/2" cal.                12         Ea             $325.00      $3,900.00          $345.00              $4,140.00                  $371.50              $4,458.00

  161      Ginko biloba 'Autumn Gold', 2" to 2 1/2" cal.                       16         Ea             $430.00      $6,880.00          $314.00              $5,024.00                  $338.00              $5,408.00

  162      Gleditsia t.i. 'Skyline', 2" to 2 1/2" cal.                         15         Ea             $290.00      $4,350.00          $225.00              $3,375.00                  $242.00              $3,630.00

  163      Phellodendron amurensis Macho, 2" to 2 1/2" cal.                     4         Ea             $425.00      $1,700.00          $305.00              $1,220.00                  $328.50              $1,314.00

  164      Platanus x acerfolia 'Morton Circle Exclamation', 2" to 2 1         16         Ea             $300.00      $4,800.00          $285.00              $4,560.00                  $307.00              $4,912.00

  165      Pyrus calleryana 'Cleveland select', 2" to 2 1/2" cal.              20         Ea             $290.00      $5,800.00          $245.00              $4,900.00                  $263.50              $5,270.00

  166      Quercus robur 'Fastigiata', 2" to 2 1/2" cal.                        3         Ea             $365.00      $1,095.00          $335.00              $1,005.00                  $360.50              $1,081.50




         page 7 of 24                                                                                                              S:\2014\2140401 City of Muskegon\CDS\bid tab 2014-01-27 Muskegon & Webster Ave.xlsx
         3355 Evergreen Dr. NE Grand Rapids, MI 49525
         t. (616) 364-8491 f. (616) 364-6955
                                                                                                                                                             Bid Tabulation

Owner:                                                                              1st                            2nd                                            3rd
  City of Muskegon
Project Title:                                                                        Jackson-Merkey Contractors         McCormick Sand, Inc.                           Brenner Excavating, Inc.
  Webster Avenue & Muskegon Avenue Street Reconstruction and Utility Improvements          3430 Lund Avenue               5430 Russell Road                               2841 132nd Avenue
Bid Date & Time:                                              Project #:                 Muskegon, MI 49442              Twin Lake, MI 49457                              Hopkins, MI 49328
  January 27, 2015 at 2:00 PM                                   2140401


Item No.                           Description                   Quantity    Unit     Unit Price    Total Amount     Unit Price           Total Amount               Unit Price           Total Amount

  167      Quercus rubra, 2" to 2 1/2" cal.                          9        Ea          $345.00     $3,105.00          $300.00              $2,700.00                  $323.00              $2,907.00

  168      Syringa reticulata Ivory Silk, 2" to 2 1/2" cal.         10        Ea          $315.00     $3,150.00          $235.00              $2,350.00                  $253.00              $2,530.00

  169      Tilia cordata 'Corzam', 2" to 2 1/2" cal.                 5        Ea          $365.00     $1,825.00          $275.00              $1,375.00                  $296.00              $1,480.00

  170      Ulmus x. Accolade, 2" to 2 1/2" cal.                     20        Ea          $325.00     $6,500.00          $280.00              $5,600.00                  $301.50              $6,030.00

  171      Zelkova serrata 'Green Vase', 2" to 2 1/2" cal.          18        Ea          $365.00     $6,570.00          $285.00              $5,130.00                  $307.00              $5,526.00

  * Denotes correction made by Engineer




         page 8 of 24                                                                                              S:\2014\2140401 City of Muskegon\CDS\bid tab 2014-01-27 Muskegon & Webster Ave.xlsx
         3355 Evergreen Dr. NE Grand Rapids, MI 49525
         t. (616) 364-8491 f. (616) 364-6955
                                                                                                                                                                           Bid Tabulation

Owner:                                                                                          4th                              5th                                            6th
  City of Muskegon
Project Title:                                                                                    Kamminga & Roodvoets, Inc.           Schippers Excavating Inc.                   Jack Dykstra Excavating, Inc.
  Webster Avenue & Muskegon Avenue Street Reconstruction and Utility Improvements                     3435 Broadmoor SE                9829 Lake Michigan Drive                       3677 - 3 Mile Road NW
Bid Date & Time:                                                    Project #:                      Grand Rapids, MI 49512              West Olive, MI 49460                         Grand Rapids, MI 49534
  January 27, 2015 at 2:00 PM                                         2140401


Item No.                           Description                          Quantity      Unit        Unit Price      Total Amount     Unit Price           Total Amount               Unit Price           Total Amount

           Miscellaneous Project Items

    1      Mobilization, Max. $300,000                                     1           LS       $300,000.00       $300,000.00    $300,000.00            $300,000.00              $300,000.00            $300,000.00

    2      Maintaining Traffic                                             1           LS         $45,000.00       $45,000.00      $89,500.00             $89,500.00               $45,800.00             $45,800.00

    3      Sign, Rem                                                       1           LS             $1,500.00     $1,500.00          $4,500.00            $4,500.00                 $6,000.00             $6,000.00

    4      Maintenance Gravel                                            1,000        Ton               $17.50     $17,500.00             $10.00          $10,000.00                     $32.00           $32,000.00

    5      Hand Patching                                                  50          Ton              $200.00     $10,000.00           $200.00           $10,000.00                   $200.00            $10,000.00

    6      Non Haz Contaminated Material Handling and Disposal, L         500         Cyd               $25.00     $12,500.00             $25.00          $12,500.00                   $100.00            $50,000.00

    7      Subgrade Undercutting, Type II                                2,500        Cyd               $14.00     $35,000.00             $12.50          $31,250.00                     $18.70           $46,750.00

    8      Subgrade Proof-Rolling                                        2,000        Syd                $1.00      $2,000.00              $2.00            $4,000.00                      $2.00            $4,000.00

    9      High Strength Geogrid                                         2,000        Syd                $5.00     $10,000.00              $9.00          $18,000.00                       $5.20          $10,400.00

   10      Underdrain, Subgrade, 6 inch                                  1,000         Ft                $4.00      $4,000.00              $6.50            $6,500.00                      $7.40            $7,400.00

   11      Erosion Control, Silt Fence                                    200          Ft                $2.50        $500.00              $3.00              $600.00                      $3.00               $600.00

   12      Erosion Control, Inlet Protection, Fabric Drop                 200          Ea              $152.00     $30,400.00           $100.00           $20,000.00                   $160.00            $32,000.00

                                                        Miscellaneous Project Items Subtotal:                     $468,400.00                           $506,850.00                                     $544,950.00


           Pavement Marking & Signing                                      0

   13      Pavt Mrkg, Polyurea, 4 inch, White                            3,285         Ft                $0.45      $1,478.25              $0.50            $1,642.50                      $0.50            $1,642.50

   14      Pavt Mrkg, Polyurea, 4 inch, Yellow                          19,895         Ft                $0.45      $8,952.75              $0.50            $9,947.50                      $0.50            $9,947.50

   15      Pavt Mrkg, Polyurea, 12 inch Cross Hatching, White             860          Ft                $4.15      $3,569.00              $5.00            $4,300.00                      $4.20            $3,612.00

   16      Pavt Mrkg, Polyurea, 12 inch Cross Hatching, Yellow            110          Ft                $4.15        $456.50              $5.00              $550.00                      $4.20               $462.00

   17      Pavt Mrkg, Polyurea, 24 inch, Stop Bar                        1,415         Ft                $9.00     $12,735.00             $10.00          $14,150.00                       $9.00          $12,735.00

   18      Pavt Mrkg, Polyurea, 6 inch, Crosswalk                        8,350         Ft                $2.25     $18,787.50              $3.00          $25,050.00                       $2.30          $19,205.00

   19      Pavt Mrkg, Polyurea, Lt Turn Arrow Sym                         12           Ea              $115.00      $1,380.00           $125.00             $1,500.00                  $120.00              $1,440.00

   20      Pavt Mrkg, Polyurea, Rt Turn Arrow Sym                          1           Ea              $115.00        $115.00           $125.00               $125.00                  $120.00                 $120.00

   21      Pavt Mrkg, Polyurea, Thru Arrow Sym                             1           Ea              $105.00        $105.00           $120.00               $120.00                  $110.00                 $110.00

   22      Pavt Mrkg, Polyurea, Only                                      14           Ea              $125.00      $1,750.00           $140.00             $1,960.00                  $130.00              $1,820.00

   23      Pavt Mrkg, Polyurea, Sharrow, Symbol                           96           Ea              $140.00     $13,440.00           $150.00           $14,400.00                   $145.00            $13,920.00




         page 9 of 24                                                                                                            S:\2014\2140401 City of Muskegon\CDS\bid tab 2014-01-27 Muskegon & Webster Ave.xlsx
         3355 Evergreen Dr. NE Grand Rapids, MI 49525
         t. (616) 364-8491 f. (616) 364-6955
                                                                                                                                                                       Bid Tabulation

Owner:                                                                                      4th                              5th                                            6th
  City of Muskegon
Project Title:                                                                                Kamminga & Roodvoets, Inc.           Schippers Excavating Inc.                   Jack Dykstra Excavating, Inc.
  Webster Avenue & Muskegon Avenue Street Reconstruction and Utility Improvements                 3435 Broadmoor SE                9829 Lake Michigan Drive                       3677 - 3 Mile Road NW
Bid Date & Time:                                                  Project #:                    Grand Rapids, MI 49512              West Olive, MI 49460                         Grand Rapids, MI 49534
  January 27, 2015 at 2:00 PM                                       2140401


Item No.                            Description                      Quantity     Unit        Unit Price      Total Amount     Unit Price           Total Amount               Unit Price           Total Amount

   24      Sign, Type III, Erect, Salv                                   7         Ea               $25.00        $175.00             $50.00              $350.00                    $25.00                $175.00

   25      Sign, Type IIIA                                              472        Sft              $16.50      $7,788.00             $18.00            $8,496.00                    $17.00             $8,024.00

   26      Sign, Type IIIB                                              197        Sft              $13.50      $2,659.50             $15.00            $2,955.00                    $14.00             $2,758.00

   27      Post, Steel, 3 lb                                           2,531       Ft                $4.45     $11,262.95              $5.00          $12,655.00                       $4.00          $10,124.00

   28      Reflective Panel for Permanent Sign Support, 6 foot          37         Ea               $30.00      $1,110.00             $40.00            $1,480.00                    $35.00             $1,295.00

   29      Post Hole Through Conc for Steel Post                        25         Ea               $30.00        $750.00             $50.00            $1,250.00                    $35.00                $875.00

                                                     Pavement Marking & Signing Subtotal:                      $86,514.45                           $100,931.00                                       $88,265.00


           Roadway Reconstruction

   30      Dr Structure, Rem                                            69         Ea              $385.00     $26,565.00           $400.00           $27,600.00                   $450.00            $31,050.00

   31      Dr Structure, Abandon                                         1         Ea              $385.00        $385.00           $250.00               $250.00                  $800.00                 $800.00

   32      Flowable Fill, Non-Structural                                10        Cyd              $120.00      $1,200.00           $150.00             $1,500.00                  $250.00              $2,500.00

   33      Sewer, Rem, Less than 24 inch                               2,515       Ft               $19.75     $49,671.25              $7.00          $17,605.00                     $13.00           $32,695.00

   34      Sewer, Rem, 24 inch to 48 inch                               390        Ft               $30.00     $11,700.00             $11.00            $4,290.00                    $15.00             $5,850.00

   35      Stump, Rem, 37 inch or Larger                                 1         Ea              $600.00        $600.00          $1,500.00            $1,500.00                  $400.00                 $400.00

   36      Sewer Bulkhead, 12 inch                                       2         Ea              $325.00        $650.00           $450.00               $900.00                  $200.00                 $400.00

   37      Pavt, Rem, Special                                           110        Sta            $1,866.00   $205,260.00          $1,900.00        $209,000.00                   $3,000.00         $330,000.00

   38      Cold Milling HMA Surface                                     925        Syd               $3.65      $3,376.25              $5.00            $4,625.00                      $5.00            $4,625.00

   39      Embankment, CIP                                             6,175      Cyd                $4.15     $25,626.25              $5.50          $33,962.50                       $7.00          $43,225.00

   40      Excavation, Earth                                          29,525      Cyd                $5.00    $147,625.00              $7.50        $221,437.50                        $9.50        $280,487.50

   41      Subbase, CIP                                               17,700      Cyd                $7.00    $123,900.00              $8.60        $152,220.00                        $9.20        $162,840.00

   42      Aggregate Base, 8 inch                                     50,530       Syd               $9.00    $454,770.00              $6.80        $343,604.00                        $6.15        $310,759.50

   43      Dr Structure, 48 inch dia                                    69         Ea             $1,375.00    $94,875.00          $2,300.00        $158,700.00                   $1,320.00           $91,080.00

   44      Dr Structure, 60 inch dia                                     5         Ea             $2,250.00    $11,250.00          $3,100.00          $15,500.00                  $2,370.00           $11,850.00

   45      Dr Structure, 72 inch dia                                     1         Ea             $3,000.00     $3,000.00          $4,700.00            $4,700.00                 $2,810.00             $2,810.00

   46      Dr Structure Cover, Type B                                   79         Ea              $305.00     $24,095.00           $750.00           $59,250.00                   $415.00            $32,785.00

   47      Dr Structure Cover, Type K                                   100        Ea              $450.00     $45,000.00           $800.00           $80,000.00                   $570.00            $57,000.00




         page 10 of 24                                                                                                       S:\2014\2140401 City of Muskegon\CDS\bid tab 2014-01-27 Muskegon & Webster Ave.xlsx
         3355 Evergreen Dr. NE Grand Rapids, MI 49525
         t. (616) 364-8491 f. (616) 364-6955
                                                                                                                                                             Bid Tabulation

Owner:                                                                              4th                            5th                                            6th
  City of Muskegon
Project Title:                                                                        Kamminga & Roodvoets, Inc.         Schippers Excavating Inc.                   Jack Dykstra Excavating, Inc.
  Webster Avenue & Muskegon Avenue Street Reconstruction and Utility Improvements         3435 Broadmoor SE              9829 Lake Michigan Drive                       3677 - 3 Mile Road NW
Bid Date & Time:                                             Project #:                 Grand Rapids, MI 49512            West Olive, MI 49460                         Grand Rapids, MI 49534
  January 27, 2015 at 2:00 PM                                  2140401


Item No.                          Description                   Quantity     Unit     Unit Price    Total Amount     Unit Price           Total Amount               Unit Price           Total Amount

   48      Dr Structure Cover, Type D                               2         Ea          $400.00       $800.00           $900.00             $1,800.00                  $510.00              $1,020.00

   49      Dr Structure Cover, Type G                               2         Ea          $260.00       $520.00           $550.00             $1,100.00                  $315.00                 $630.00

   50      Dr Structure Cover, Type Q, Modified                    27         Ea          $350.00     $9,450.00           $820.00           $22,140.00                   $430.00            $11,610.00

   51      Dr Structure Cover, Adj, Case 1                         146        Ea          $350.00    $51,100.00           $890.00         $129,940.00                    $500.00            $73,000.00

   52      Dr Structure Cover, Adj, Case 2                         13         Ea          $300.00     $3,900.00          $1,000.00          $13,000.00                   $500.00              $6,500.00

   53      Dr Structure, Tap, 12 inch                               8         Ea          $175.00     $1,400.00           $750.00             $6,000.00                  $385.00              $3,080.00

   54      Dr Structure, Tap, 30 inch                               2         Ea          $200.00       $400.00          $1,000.00            $2,000.00                  $830.00              $1,660.00

   55      Sewer, Cl E, 12 inch, Tr Det B                         1,796       Ft           $26.00    $46,696.00             $36.00          $64,656.00                     $36.05           $64,745.80

   56      Sewer, Cl E, 30 inch, Tr Det B                          331        Ft           $53.00    $17,543.00             $95.00          $31,445.00                     $76.65           $25,371.15

   57      Sewer, Cl A, 6 inch, Tr Det B                           10         Ft           $23.00       $230.00             $26.00              $260.00                    $22.75                $227.50

   58      Sewer, Cl A, 12 inch, Tr Det B                          253        Ft           $26.00     $6,578.00             $32.00            $8,096.00                    $36.05             $9,120.65

   59      Sewer, Cl A, 24 inch, Tr Det B                          24         Ft           $36.00       $864.00             $82.00            $1,968.00                    $66.85             $1,604.40

   60      Sewer, Cl A, 30 inch, Tr Det B                          16         Ft           $53.00       $848.00             $90.00            $1,440.00                    $80.95             $1,295.20

   61      Paved Ditch, HMA                                        20         Syd          $50.00     $1,000.00             $80.00            $1,600.00                  $200.00              $4,000.00

   62      Shoulder Gutter, Conc, Det 2                             1         Ea          $350.00       $350.00           $750.00               $750.00                  $685.00                 $685.00

   63      Spillway, Conc                                           7         Ft           $40.00       $280.00             $80.00              $560.00                    $48.00                $336.00

   64      HMA, 4E1                                               6,625      Ton           $78.48   $519,930.00             $82.00        $543,250.00                      $81.00         $536,625.00

   65      HMA, 3E1                                               7,790      Ton           $73.79   $574,824.10             $77.00        $599,830.00                      $80.00         $623,200.00

   66      Textured Asphalt Crosswalk                            24,715       Sft          $10.00   $247,150.00              $8.00        $197,720.00                        $5.50        $135,932.50

   67      Driveway, Nonreinf Conc, 6 inch                        1,009       Syd          $41.00    $41,369.00             $32.00          $32,288.00                     $40.45           $40,814.05

   68      Curb and Gutter, Conc, Det F4, Modified               22,034       Ft           $12.00   $264,408.00             $11.00        $242,374.00                      $17.45         $384,493.30

   69      Curb, Conc, Det E4                                      332        Ft           $23.50     $7,802.00             $25.50            $8,466.00                    $28.40             $9,428.80

   70      Driveway Opening, Conc, Det M                          1,666       Ft           $15.50    $25,823.00             $16.00          $26,656.00                     $18.75           $31,237.50

   71      Fence, Moving                                           136        Ft           $35.00     $4,760.00             $22.00            $2,992.00                    $15.00             $2,040.00

   72      Riprap, Plain                                           10         Syd          $40.00       $400.00             $60.00              $600.00                    $60.00                $600.00

   73      Slope Restoration                                     18,315       Syd           $4.55    $83,333.25              $2.60          $47,619.00                       $3.75          $68,681.25




         page 11 of 24                                                                                             S:\2014\2140401 City of Muskegon\CDS\bid tab 2014-01-27 Muskegon & Webster Ave.xlsx
         3355 Evergreen Dr. NE Grand Rapids, MI 49525
         t. (616) 364-8491 f. (616) 364-6955
                                                                                                                                                                         Bid Tabulation

Owner:                                                                                       4th                               5th                                            6th
  City of Muskegon
Project Title:                                                                                 Kamminga & Roodvoets, Inc.            Schippers Excavating Inc.                   Jack Dykstra Excavating, Inc.
  Webster Avenue & Muskegon Avenue Street Reconstruction and Utility Improvements                  3435 Broadmoor SE                 9829 Lake Michigan Drive                       3677 - 3 Mile Road NW
Bid Date & Time:                                                  Project #:                     Grand Rapids, MI 49512               West Olive, MI 49460                         Grand Rapids, MI 49534
  January 27, 2015 at 2:00 PM                                       2140401


Item No.                            Description                      Quantity      Unit        Unit Price       Total Amount     Unit Price           Total Amount               Unit Price           Total Amount

                                                         Roadway Reconstruction Subtotal:                      $3,141,307.10                       $3,325,194.00                                   $3,439,095.10


           Sidewalk

   74      Sidewalk, Rem                                               6,056       Syd                $5.35      $32,399.60              $4.00          $24,224.00                       $6.50          $39,364.00

   75      Sidewalk, Conc, 4 inch                                     40,130        Sft               $3.00     $120,390.00              $2.90        $116,377.00                        $3.90        $156,507.00

   76      Sidewalk, Conc, 6 inch                                      4,560        Sft               $4.50      $20,520.00              $3.50          $15,960.00                       $4.70          $21,432.00

   77      Sidewalk Ramp, Conc, 6 inch                                 9,215        Sft               $4.90      $45,153.50              $5.20          $47,918.00                       $6.10          $56,211.50

   78      Detectable Warning Surface                                  1,422        Ft               $40.00      $56,880.00             $35.00          $49,770.00                     $55.00           $78,210.00

                                                                        Sidewalk Subtotal:                      $275,343.10                           $254,249.00                                     $351,724.50


           Sanitary Sewer

   79      San Sewer, Rem, 6 inch                                       60          Ft               $16.00         $960.00             $20.00            $1,200.00                    $20.00             $1,200.00

   80      San Sewer, Rem, 8 inch                                       80          Ft               $16.00       $1,280.00             $20.00            $1,600.00                    $25.00             $2,000.00

   81      Abandon Well in Sanitary Manhole                              1          Ea             $2,000.00      $2,000.00          $1,500.00            $1,500.00                 $2,500.00             $2,500.00

   82      Cap Existing DI Sanitary Cleanout Riser                       1          Ea              $325.00         $325.00           $800.00               $800.00                  $500.00                 $500.00

   83      Sanitary Manhole, 48 inch dia                                 3          Ea             $2,650.00      $7,950.00          $3,450.00          $10,350.00                  $4,140.00           $12,420.00

   84      San Sewer, 6 inch, Tr Det B                                  63          Ft               $50.00       $3,150.00           $140.00             $8,820.00                    $36.00             $2,268.00

   85      San Sewer, 8 inch, Tr Det B                                  80          Ft               $55.00       $4,400.00           $150.00           $12,000.00                   $126.00            $10,080.00

   86      San Sewer, Connect to 8 inch                                 10          Ea              $300.00       $3,000.00          $1,400.00          $14,000.00                   $200.00              $2,000.00

                                                                  Sanitary Sewer Subtotal:                       $23,065.00                             $50,270.00                                      $32,968.00


           Water Main

   87      Hydrant, Rem                                                 16          Ea              $500.00       $8,000.00           $400.00             $6,400.00                 $1,000.00           $16,000.00

   88      Hydrant, Adj                                                  2          Ea              $675.00       $1,350.00           $550.00             $1,100.00                 $1,000.00             $2,000.00

   89      Water Main, Valve and Box, 6 inch, Rem                        1          Ea              $350.00         $350.00           $500.00               $500.00                  $500.00                 $500.00

   90      Water Main, Valve and Box, 8 inch, Rem                        1          Ea              $350.00         $350.00           $500.00               $500.00                  $500.00                 $500.00

   91      Water Main, Valve and Manhole, 16 inch, Rem                   4          Ea              $350.00       $1,400.00           $800.00             $3,200.00                  $800.00              $3,200.00

   92      Water Main, Valve and Manhole, 20 inch, Rem                   1          Ea              $500.00         $500.00           $900.00               $900.00                 $1,000.00             $1,000.00

   93      Water Main, Valve Manhole, Rem                                1          Ea              $350.00         $350.00           $400.00               $400.00                  $500.00                 $500.00




         page 12 of 24                                                                                                         S:\2014\2140401 City of Muskegon\CDS\bid tab 2014-01-27 Muskegon & Webster Ave.xlsx
         3355 Evergreen Dr. NE Grand Rapids, MI 49525
         t. (616) 364-8491 f. (616) 364-6955
                                                                                                                                                               Bid Tabulation

Owner:                                                                              4th                              5th                                            6th
  City of Muskegon
Project Title:                                                                        Kamminga & Roodvoets, Inc.           Schippers Excavating Inc.                   Jack Dykstra Excavating, Inc.
  Webster Avenue & Muskegon Avenue Street Reconstruction and Utility Improvements         3435 Broadmoor SE                9829 Lake Michigan Drive                       3677 - 3 Mile Road NW
Bid Date & Time:                                             Project #:                 Grand Rapids, MI 49512              West Olive, MI 49460                         Grand Rapids, MI 49534
  January 27, 2015 at 2:00 PM                                  2140401


Item No.                         Description                    Quantity     Unit     Unit Price      Total Amount     Unit Price           Total Amount               Unit Price           Total Amount

   94      Water Main, Abandoned Valve Box, Rem                    33         Ea           $175.00      $5,775.00           $250.00             $8,250.00                  $250.00              $8,250.00

   95      Water Main, Plug, 4 inch                                 1         Ea           $350.00        $350.00           $200.00               $200.00                  $475.00                 $475.00

   96      Water Main, Plug, 6 inch                                 7         Ea           $395.00      $2,765.00           $230.00             $1,610.00                  $505.00              $3,535.00

   97      Water Main, Plug, 8 inch                                 1         Ea           $400.00        $400.00           $280.00               $280.00                  $545.00                 $545.00

   98      Water Main, Cap, 4 inch                                  1         Ea           $400.00        $400.00           $180.00               $180.00                  $465.00                 $465.00

   99      Water Main, Cap, 6 inch                                  6         Ea           $415.00      $2,490.00           $250.00             $1,500.00                  $480.00              $2,880.00

  100      Water Main, Cap or Plug, 6 inch                         26         Ea           $415.00     $10,790.00           $250.00             $6,500.00                  $505.00            $13,130.00

  101      Water Main, Cap or Plug, 8 inch                          3         Ea           $480.00      $1,440.00           $300.00               $900.00                  $545.00              $1,635.00

  102      Water Main, Temporary Cap, 6 inch                        7         Ea           $625.00      $4,375.00           $400.00             $2,800.00                  $480.00              $3,360.00

  103      Water Main, Valve Box, Adj                              37         Ea           $300.00     $11,100.00           $250.00             $9,250.00                  $350.00            $12,950.00

  104      Water Main, Meter Box, Adj                               1         Ea           $500.00        $500.00           $350.00               $350.00                  $800.00                 $800.00

  105      Water Main, DI, 4 inch, Tr Det G                        61         Ft            $36.00      $2,196.00             $58.00            $3,538.00                    $48.50             $2,958.50

  106      Water Main, DI, 6 inch, Tr Det G                        191        Ft            $38.85      $7,420.35             $58.00          $11,078.00                     $48.35             $9,234.85

  107      Water Main, DI, 8 inch, Tr Det G                       5,264       Ft            $36.00    $189,504.00             $64.00        $336,896.00                      $53.00         $278,992.00

  108      Water Main, DI, 16 inch, Tr Det G                       30         Ft           $150.00      $4,500.00           $150.00             $4,500.00                  $190.15              $5,704.50

  109      Water Main, DI, 20 inch, Tr Det G                       10         Ft           $200.00      $2,000.00           $195.00             $1,950.00                  $262.45              $2,624.50

  110      Water Main, Valve and Box, 4 inch                        2         Ea          $1,200.00     $2,400.00           $850.00             $1,700.00                  $910.00              $1,820.00

  111      Water Main, Valve and Box, 6 inch                        9         Ea          $1,300.00    $11,700.00           $950.00             $8,550.00                 $1,020.00             $9,180.00

  112      Water Main, Valve and Box, 8 inch                       18         Ea          $1,550.00    $27,900.00          $1,350.00          $24,300.00                  $1,335.00           $24,030.00

  113      Water Main, Valve and Box, 16 inch                       4         Ea          $3,750.00    $15,000.00          $6,250.00          $25,000.00                  $6,370.00           $25,480.00

  114      Water Main, 11 1/4 Degree Bend, 8 inch                   1         Ea           $530.00        $530.00           $350.00               $350.00                  $310.00                 $310.00

  115      Water Main, 45 Degree Bend, 8 inch                      37         Ea           $750.00     $27,750.00           $360.00           $13,320.00                   $330.00            $12,210.00

  116      Water Main, Tee, 8 inch x 8 inch x 6 inch               10         Ea           $725.00      $7,250.00           $500.00             $5,000.00                  $480.00              $4,800.00

  117      Water Main, Tee, 8 inch x 8 inch x 8 inch                1         Ea           $760.00        $760.00           $550.00               $550.00                  $530.00                 $530.00

  118      Water Main, Cross, 8 inch x 8 inch                       3         Ea          $1,015.00     $3,045.00           $800.00             $2,400.00                  $740.00              $2,220.00

  119      Water Main, Cross, 16 inch x 8 inch                      1         Ea          $2,000.00     $2,000.00          $2,000.00            $2,000.00                 $1,980.00             $1,980.00




         page 13 of 24                                                                                               S:\2014\2140401 City of Muskegon\CDS\bid tab 2014-01-27 Muskegon & Webster Ave.xlsx
         3355 Evergreen Dr. NE Grand Rapids, MI 49525
         t. (616) 364-8491 f. (616) 364-6955
                                                                                                                                                                             Bid Tabulation

Owner:                                                                                            4th                              5th                                            6th
  City of Muskegon
Project Title:                                                                                      Kamminga & Roodvoets, Inc.           Schippers Excavating Inc.                   Jack Dykstra Excavating, Inc.
  Webster Avenue & Muskegon Avenue Street Reconstruction and Utility Improvements                       3435 Broadmoor SE                9829 Lake Michigan Drive                       3677 - 3 Mile Road NW
Bid Date & Time:                                                        Project #:                    Grand Rapids, MI 49512              West Olive, MI 49460                         Grand Rapids, MI 49534
  January 27, 2015 at 2:00 PM                                             2140401


Item No.                           Description                             Quantity     Unit        Unit Price      Total Amount     Unit Price           Total Amount               Unit Price           Total Amount

  120      Water Main, Sleeve, 4 inch                                          2         Ea             $1,030.00     $2,060.00          $1,350.00            $2,700.00                  $900.00              $1,800.00

  121      Water Main, Sleeve, 6 inch                                          1         Ea             $1,400.00     $1,400.00          $1,500.00            $1,500.00                  $970.00                 $970.00

  122      Water Main, Sleeve, 8 inch                                         13         Ea             $1,100.00    $14,300.00          $1,700.00          $22,100.00                  $1,075.00           $13,975.00

  123      Water Main, Sleeve, 16 inch                                         8         Ea             $2,600.00    $20,800.00          $3,800.00          $30,400.00                  $3,511.00           $28,088.00

  124      Water Main, Sleeve, 20 inch                                         2         Ea             $4,250.00     $8,500.00          $4,200.00            $8,400.00                 $2,640.00             $5,280.00

  125      Water Main, Reducer, 8 inch x 6 inch                               11         Ea              $450.00      $4,950.00           $350.00             $3,850.00                  $340.00              $3,740.00

  126      Water Main, Tapping Tee and Valve, 16 inch x 16 inch x              4         Ea             $4,150.00    $16,600.00          $4,200.00          $16,800.00                  $4,345.00           $17,380.00

  127      Water Main, Tapping Tee and Valve, 20 inch x 20 inch x 4            2         Ea             $3,400.00     $6,800.00          $3,600.00            $7,200.00                 $3,805.00             $7,610.00

  128      Water Main, Tapping Tee and Valve, 20 inch x 20 inch x 6            3         Ea             $3,650.00    $10,950.00          $3,800.00          $11,400.00                  $4,045.00           $12,135.00

  129      Fire Hydrant                                                       12         Ea             $2,500.00    $30,000.00          $2,550.00          $30,600.00                  $2,525.00           $30,300.00

  130      Investigate Location, Material, and Size of Existing Water         53         Ea              $400.00     $21,200.00           $400.00           $21,200.00                   $600.00            $31,800.00

  131      Water Service, Remove and Plug Existing Tap                         0         Ea                               $0.00          $1,200.00                  $0.00                                           $0.00

  132      Water Service, 1 inch                                             3,175       Ft               $29.25     $92,868.75             $24.00          $76,200.00                     $24.00           $76,200.00

  133      Water Service, 2 inch                                              731        Ft               $38.25     $27,960.75             $36.00          $26,316.00                     $30.50           $22,295.50

  134      Water Service, Corporation Stop, 1 inch                            95         Ea              $325.00     $30,875.00           $400.00           $38,000.00                   $150.00            $14,250.00

  135      Water Service, Corporation Stop, 2 inch                            22         Ea              $700.00     $15,400.00           $950.00           $20,900.00                   $650.00            $14,300.00

  136      Water Service, Curb Stop and Box, 1 inch                           95         Ea              $425.00     $40,375.00           $350.00           $33,250.00                   $230.00            $21,850.00

  137      Water Service, Curb Stop and Box, 2 inch                           22         Ea              $725.00     $15,950.00           $700.00           $15,400.00                   $570.00            $12,540.00

                                                                           Water Main Subtotal:                     $717,629.85                           $852,168.00                                     $768,312.85


           Landscaping

  138      Acer freemani 'Celzam', 2 1/2" cal.                                 9         Ea              $375.00      $3,375.00           $350.00             $3,150.00                  $375.00              $3,375.00

  139      Acer freemani 'Jeffersred', 2 1/2" cal.                            14         Ea              $375.00      $5,250.00           $350.00             $4,900.00                  $375.00              $5,250.00

  140      Acer platanoides 'Crimson King', 2 1/2" cal.                       13         Ea              $325.00      $4,225.00           $320.00             $4,160.00                  $325.00              $4,225.00

  141      Acer rubrum 'Franksred', 2 1/2" cal.                                8         Ea              $385.00      $3,080.00           $400.00             $3,200.00                  $385.00              $3,080.00

  142      Celtis occidentalis 'All Seasons', 2 1/2" cal.                     12         Ea              $400.00      $4,800.00           $350.00             $4,200.00                  $400.00              $4,800.00

  143      Ginko biloba 'Autumn Gold', 2 1/2" cal.                            16         Ea              $355.00      $5,680.00           $400.00             $6,400.00                  $355.00              $5,680.00




         page 14 of 24                                                                                                             S:\2014\2140401 City of Muskegon\CDS\bid tab 2014-01-27 Muskegon & Webster Ave.xlsx
         3355 Evergreen Dr. NE Grand Rapids, MI 49525
         t. (616) 364-8491 f. (616) 364-6955
                                                                                                                                                                             Bid Tabulation

Owner:                                                                                             4th                             5th                                            6th
  City of Muskegon
Project Title:                                                                                       Kamminga & Roodvoets, Inc.          Schippers Excavating Inc.                   Jack Dykstra Excavating, Inc.
  Webster Avenue & Muskegon Avenue Street Reconstruction and Utility Improvements                        3435 Broadmoor SE               9829 Lake Michigan Drive                       3677 - 3 Mile Road NW
Bid Date & Time:                                                         Project #:                    Grand Rapids, MI 49512             West Olive, MI 49460                         Grand Rapids, MI 49534
  January 27, 2015 at 2:00 PM                                              2140401


Item No.                             Description                            Quantity      Unit       Unit Price     Total Amount     Unit Price           Total Amount               Unit Price           Total Amount

  144      Gleditsia t.i. 'Skyline', 2 1/2" cal.                               15         Ea             $275.00      $4,125.00           $300.00             $4,500.00                  $275.00              $4,125.00

  145      Phellodendron amurensis Macho, 2 1/2" cal.                           4         Ea             $355.00      $1,420.00           $400.00             $1,600.00                  $355.00              $1,420.00

  146      Platanus x acerfolia 'Morton Circle Exclamation', 2 1/2" ca         16         Ea             $333.00      $5,328.00           $350.00             $5,600.00                  $335.00              $5,360.00

  147      Pyrus calleryana 'Cleveland select', 2 1/2" cal.                    20         Ea             $285.00      $5,700.00           $300.00             $6,000.00                  $285.00              $5,700.00

  148      Quercus robur 'Fastigiata', 2 1/2" cal.                              3         Ea             $380.00      $1,140.00           $380.00             $1,140.00                  $380.00              $1,140.00

  149      Quercus rubra, 2 1/2" cal.                                           9         Ea             $340.00      $3,060.00           $350.00             $3,150.00                  $340.00              $3,060.00

  150      Syringa reticulata Ivory Silk, 2 1/2" cal.                          10         Ea             $282.00      $2,820.00           $300.00             $3,000.00                  $285.00              $2,850.00

  151      Tilia cordata 'Corzam', 2 1/2" cal.                                  5         Ea             $335.00      $1,675.00           $350.00             $1,750.00                  $335.00              $1,675.00

  152      Ulmus x. Accolade, 2 1/2" cal.                                      20         Ea             $317.00      $6,340.00           $350.00             $7,000.00                  $320.00              $6,400.00

  153      Zelkova serrata 'Green Vase', 2 1/2" cal.                           18         Ea             $335.00      $6,030.00           $380.00             $6,840.00                  $335.00              $6,030.00

  154      Tree Gator Bags, Supply, Install and Fill                           192        Ea              $20.00      $3,840.00             $50.00            $9,600.00                    $40.00             $7,680.00

                                                                           Landscaping Subtotal:                     $67,888.00                             $76,190.00                                      $71,850.00


                                                                                       Total Bid                   $4,780,147.50                       $5,165,852.00                                   $5,297,165.45


           Alternate Bid Items

  155      Aggregate Base, 8 inch, 21AA                                      50,530       Syd             $10.00    $505,300.00              $8.70        $439,611.00                        $8.45        $426,978.50

  156      Acer freemani 'Celzam', 2" to 2 1/2" cal.                            9         Ea             $275.00      $2,475.00           $300.00             $2,700.00                  $275.00              $2,475.00

  157      Acer freemani 'Jeffersred', 2" to 2 1/2" cal.                       14         Ea             $325.00      $4,550.00           $300.00             $4,200.00                  $325.00              $4,550.00

  158      Acer platanoides 'Crimson King', 2" to 2 1/2" cal.                  13         Ea             $295.00      $3,835.00           $290.00             $3,770.00                  $295.00              $3,835.00

  159      Acer rubrum 'Franksred', 2" to 2 1/2" cal.                           8         Ea             $335.00      $2,680.00           $350.00             $2,800.00                  $335.00              $2,680.00

  160      Celtis occidentalis 'All Seasons', 2" to 2 1/2" cal.                12         Ea             $345.00      $4,140.00           $330.00             $3,960.00                  $345.00              $4,140.00

  161      Ginko biloba 'Autumn Gold', 2" to 2 1/2" cal.                       16         Ea             $314.00      $5,024.00           $370.00             $5,920.00                  $315.00              $5,040.00

  162      Gleditsia t.i. 'Skyline', 2" to 2 1/2" cal.                         15         Ea             $225.00      $3,375.00           $270.00             $4,050.00                  $225.00              $3,375.00

  163      Phellodendron amurensis Macho, 2" to 2 1/2" cal.                     4         Ea             $305.00      $1,220.00           $350.00             $1,400.00                  $305.00              $1,220.00

  164      Platanus x acerfolia 'Morton Circle Exclamation', 2" to 2 1         16         Ea             $285.00      $4,560.00           $320.00             $5,120.00                  $285.00              $4,560.00

  165      Pyrus calleryana 'Cleveland select', 2" to 2 1/2" cal.              20         Ea             $245.00      $4,900.00           $280.00             $5,600.00                  $245.00              $4,900.00

  166      Quercus robur 'Fastigiata', 2" to 2 1/2" cal.                        3         Ea             $335.00      $1,005.00           $350.00             $1,050.00                  $335.00              $1,005.00




         page 15 of 24                                                                                                             S:\2014\2140401 City of Muskegon\CDS\bid tab 2014-01-27 Muskegon & Webster Ave.xlsx
         3355 Evergreen Dr. NE Grand Rapids, MI 49525
         t. (616) 364-8491 f. (616) 364-6955
                                                                                                                                                             Bid Tabulation

Owner:                                                                              4th                            5th                                            6th
  City of Muskegon
Project Title:                                                                        Kamminga & Roodvoets, Inc.         Schippers Excavating Inc.                   Jack Dykstra Excavating, Inc.
  Webster Avenue & Muskegon Avenue Street Reconstruction and Utility Improvements         3435 Broadmoor SE              9829 Lake Michigan Drive                       3677 - 3 Mile Road NW
Bid Date & Time:                                              Project #:                Grand Rapids, MI 49512            West Olive, MI 49460                         Grand Rapids, MI 49534
  January 27, 2015 at 2:00 PM                                   2140401


Item No.                           Description                   Quantity    Unit     Unit Price    Total Amount     Unit Price           Total Amount               Unit Price           Total Amount

  167      Quercus rubra, 2" to 2 1/2" cal.                          9        Ea          $300.00     $2,700.00           $320.00             $2,880.00                  $300.00              $2,700.00

  168      Syringa reticulata Ivory Silk, 2" to 2 1/2" cal.         10        Ea          $235.00     $2,350.00           $280.00             $2,800.00                  $235.00              $2,350.00

  169      Tilia cordata 'Corzam', 2" to 2 1/2" cal.                 5        Ea          $275.00     $1,375.00           $320.00             $1,600.00                  $275.00              $1,375.00

  170      Ulmus x. Accolade, 2" to 2 1/2" cal.                     20        Ea          $280.00     $5,600.00           $320.00             $6,400.00                  $280.00              $5,600.00

  171      Zelkova serrata 'Green Vase', 2" to 2 1/2" cal.          18        Ea          $285.00     $5,130.00           $350.00             $6,300.00                  $285.00              $5,130.00

  * Denotes correction made by Engineer




         page 16 of 24                                                                                             S:\2014\2140401 City of Muskegon\CDS\bid tab 2014-01-27 Muskegon & Webster Ave.xlsx
3355 Evergreen Dr. NE Grand Rapids, MI 49525
t. (616) 364-8491 f. (616) 364-6955
                                                                                                                                                               Bid Tabulation

                     Owner:                                                                                          7th
                       City of Muskegon
                     Project Title:                                                                                    DJ McQuestion & Sons, Inc.
                                                                                                                           17708 18 Mile Road
                       Webster Avenue & Muskegon Avenue Street Reconstruction and Utility Improvements
                                                                                                                            LeRoy, MI 49655
                     Bid Date & Time:                                                    Project #:
                       January 27, 2015 at 2:00 PM                                         2140401


                     Item No.                           Description                          Quantity      Unit        Unit Price           Total Amount

                                Miscellaneous Project Items

                         1      Mobilization, Max. $300,000                                     1           LS       $300,000.00            $300,000.00

                         2      Maintaining Traffic                                             1           LS       $387,000.00            $387,000.00

                         3      Sign, Rem                                                       1           LS             $1,500.00            $1,500.00

                         4      Maintenance Gravel                                            1,000        Ton               $10.00           $10,000.00

                         5      Hand Patching                                                  50          Ton              $200.00           $10,000.00

                         6      Non Haz Contaminated Material Handling and Disposal, L         500         Cyd               $45.00           $22,500.00

                         7      Subgrade Undercutting, Type II                                2,500        Cyd               $17.50           $43,750.00

                         8      Subgrade Proof-Rolling                                        2,000        Syd                 $0.50            $1,000.00

                         9      High Strength Geogrid                                         2,000        Syd                 $3.75            $7,500.00

                        10      Underdrain, Subgrade, 6 inch                                  1,000         Ft                 $3.50            $3,500.00

                        11      Erosion Control, Silt Fence                                    200          Ft                 $3.00              $600.00

                        12      Erosion Control, Inlet Protection, Fabric Drop                 200          Ea               $60.00           $12,000.00

                                                                             Miscellaneous Project Items Subtotal:                          $799,350.00


                                Pavement Marking & Signing                                      0

                        13      Pavt Mrkg, Polyurea, 4 inch, White                            3,285         Ft                 $0.45            $1,478.25

                        14      Pavt Mrkg, Polyurea, 4 inch, Yellow                          19,895         Ft                 $0.45            $8,952.75

                        15      Pavt Mrkg, Polyurea, 12 inch Cross Hatching, White             860          Ft                 $4.15            $3,569.00

                        16      Pavt Mrkg, Polyurea, 12 inch Cross Hatching, Yellow            110          Ft                 $4.15              $456.50

                        17      Pavt Mrkg, Polyurea, 24 inch, Stop Bar                        1,415         Ft                 $9.00          $12,735.00

                        18      Pavt Mrkg, Polyurea, 6 inch, Crosswalk                        8,350         Ft                 $2.25          $18,787.50

                        19      Pavt Mrkg, Polyurea, Lt Turn Arrow Sym                         12           Ea              $115.00             $1,380.00

                        20      Pavt Mrkg, Polyurea, Rt Turn Arrow Sym                          1           Ea              $115.00               $115.00

                        21      Pavt Mrkg, Polyurea, Thru Arrow Sym                             1           Ea              $105.00               $105.00

                        22      Pavt Mrkg, Polyurea, Only                                      14           Ea              $125.00             $1,750.00

                        23      Pavt Mrkg, Polyurea, Sharrow, Symbol                           96           Ea              $140.00           $13,440.00




page 17 of 24                                                                                                        S:\2014\2140401 City of Muskegon\CDS\bid tab 2014-01-27 Muskegon & Webster Ave.xlsx
3355 Evergreen Dr. NE Grand Rapids, MI 49525
t. (616) 364-8491 f. (616) 364-6955
                                                                                                                                                           Bid Tabulation

                     Owner:                                                                                      7th
                       City of Muskegon
                     Project Title:                                                                                DJ McQuestion & Sons, Inc.
                                                                                                                       17708 18 Mile Road
                       Webster Avenue & Muskegon Avenue Street Reconstruction and Utility Improvements
                                                                                                                        LeRoy, MI 49655
                     Bid Date & Time:                                                  Project #:
                       January 27, 2015 at 2:00 PM                                       2140401


                     Item No.                            Description                      Quantity     Unit        Unit Price           Total Amount

                        24      Sign, Type III, Erect, Salv                                   7         Ea               $25.00               $175.00

                        25      Sign, Type IIIA                                              472        Sft              $16.50             $7,788.00

                        26      Sign, Type IIIB                                              197        Sft              $13.50             $2,659.50

                        27      Post, Steel, 3 lb                                           2,531       Ft                 $3.95            $9,997.45

                        28      Reflective Panel for Permanent Sign Support, 6 foot          37         Ea               $30.00             $1,110.00

                        29      Post Hole Through Conc for Steel Post                        25         Ea               $30.00               $750.00

                                                                          Pavement Marking & Signing Subtotal:                            $85,248.95


                                Roadway Reconstruction

                        30      Dr Structure, Rem                                            69         Ea              $300.00           $20,700.00

                        31      Dr Structure, Abandon                                         1         Ea              $250.00               $250.00

                        32      Flowable Fill, Non-Structural                                10        Cyd              $100.00             $1,000.00

                        33      Sewer, Rem, Less than 24 inch                               2,515       Ft               $15.00           $37,725.00

                        34      Sewer, Rem, 24 inch to 48 inch                               390        Ft               $15.00             $5,850.00

                        35      Stump, Rem, 37 inch or Larger                                 1         Ea              $300.00               $300.00

                        36      Sewer Bulkhead, 12 inch                                       2         Ea              $250.00               $500.00

                        37      Pavt, Rem, Special                                           110        Sta            $8,050.00        $885,500.00

                        38      Cold Milling HMA Surface                                     925        Syd                $5.00            $4,625.00

                        39      Embankment, CIP                                             6,175      Cyd                 $6.00          $37,050.00

                        40      Excavation, Earth                                          29,525      Cyd                 $0.01              $295.25

                        41      Subbase, CIP                                               17,700      Cyd                 $0.01              $177.00

                        42      Aggregate Base, 8 inch                                     50,530       Syd                $6.00        $303,180.00

                        43      Dr Structure, 48 inch dia                                    69         Ea             $1,550.00        $106,950.00

                        44      Dr Structure, 60 inch dia                                     5         Ea             $2,850.00          $14,250.00

                        45      Dr Structure, 72 inch dia                                     1         Ea             $3,500.00            $3,500.00

                        46      Dr Structure Cover, Type B                                   79         Ea              $575.00           $45,425.00

                        47      Dr Structure Cover, Type K                                   100        Ea              $780.00           $78,000.00




page 18 of 24                                                                                                    S:\2014\2140401 City of Muskegon\CDS\bid tab 2014-01-27 Muskegon & Webster Ave.xlsx
3355 Evergreen Dr. NE Grand Rapids, MI 49525
t. (616) 364-8491 f. (616) 364-6955
                                                                                                                                                   Bid Tabulation

                     Owner:                                                                              7th
                       City of Muskegon
                     Project Title:                                                                        DJ McQuestion & Sons, Inc.
                                                                                                               17708 18 Mile Road
                       Webster Avenue & Muskegon Avenue Street Reconstruction and Utility Improvements
                                                                                                                LeRoy, MI 49655
                     Bid Date & Time:                                             Project #:
                       January 27, 2015 at 2:00 PM                                  2140401


                     Item No.                          Description                   Quantity     Unit     Unit Price           Total Amount

                        48      Dr Structure Cover, Type D                               2         Ea          $700.00              $1,400.00

                        49      Dr Structure Cover, Type G                               2         Ea          $515.00              $1,030.00

                        50      Dr Structure Cover, Type Q, Modified                    27         Ea          $625.00            $16,875.00

                        51      Dr Structure Cover, Adj, Case 1                         146        Ea          $350.00            $51,100.00

                        52      Dr Structure Cover, Adj, Case 2                         13         Ea          $350.00              $4,550.00

                        53      Dr Structure, Tap, 12 inch                               8         Ea          $500.00              $4,000.00

                        54      Dr Structure, Tap, 30 inch                               2         Ea          $750.00              $1,500.00

                        55      Sewer, Cl E, 12 inch, Tr Det B                         1,796       Ft            $35.00           $62,860.00

                        56      Sewer, Cl E, 30 inch, Tr Det B                          331        Ft            $67.50           $22,342.50

                        57      Sewer, Cl A, 6 inch, Tr Det B                           10         Ft            $33.50               $335.00

                        58      Sewer, Cl A, 12 inch, Tr Det B                          253        Ft            $35.00             $8,855.00

                        59      Sewer, Cl A, 24 inch, Tr Det B                          24         Ft            $55.00             $1,320.00

                        60      Sewer, Cl A, 30 inch, Tr Det B                          16         Ft            $70.00             $1,120.00

                        61      Paved Ditch, HMA                                        20         Syd           $60.00             $1,200.00

                        62      Shoulder Gutter, Conc, Det 2                             1         Ea          $550.00                $550.00

                        63      Spillway, Conc                                           7         Ft            $65.00               $455.00

                        64      HMA, 4E1                                               6,625      Ton            $78.48         $519,930.00

                        65      HMA, 3E1                                               7,790      Ton            $73.79         $574,824.10

                        66      Textured Asphalt Crosswalk                            24,715       Sft             $5.30        $130,989.50

                        67      Driveway, Nonreinf Conc, 6 inch                        1,009       Syd           $30.15           $30,421.35

                        68      Curb and Gutter, Conc, Det F4, Modified               22,034       Ft            $11.15         $245,679.10

                        69      Curb, Conc, Det E4                                      332        Ft            $25.00             $8,300.00

                        70      Driveway Opening, Conc, Det M                          1,666       Ft            $16.00           $26,656.00

                        71      Fence, Moving                                           136        Ft            $20.00             $2,720.00

                        72      Riprap, Plain                                           10         Syd           $60.00               $600.00

                        73      Slope Restoration                                     18,315       Syd             $3.50          $64,102.50




page 19 of 24                                                                                            S:\2014\2140401 City of Muskegon\CDS\bid tab 2014-01-27 Muskegon & Webster Ave.xlsx
3355 Evergreen Dr. NE Grand Rapids, MI 49525
t. (616) 364-8491 f. (616) 364-6955
                                                                                                                                                            Bid Tabulation

                     Owner:                                                                                       7th
                       City of Muskegon
                     Project Title:                                                                                 DJ McQuestion & Sons, Inc.
                                                                                                                        17708 18 Mile Road
                       Webster Avenue & Muskegon Avenue Street Reconstruction and Utility Improvements
                                                                                                                         LeRoy, MI 49655
                     Bid Date & Time:                                                  Project #:
                       January 27, 2015 at 2:00 PM                                       2140401


                     Item No.                            Description                      Quantity      Unit        Unit Price           Total Amount

                                                                              Roadway Reconstruction Subtotal:                        $3,328,992.30


                                Sidewalk

                        74      Sidewalk, Rem                                               6,056       Syd                 $8.00          $48,448.00

                        75      Sidewalk, Conc, 4 inch                                     40,130        Sft                $2.80        $112,364.00

                        76      Sidewalk, Conc, 6 inch                                      4,560        Sft                $3.35          $15,276.00

                        77      Sidewalk Ramp, Conc, 6 inch                                 9,215        Sft                $4.75          $43,771.25

                        78      Detectable Warning Surface                                  1,422        Ft               $32.00           $45,504.00

                                                                                             Sidewalk Subtotal:                          $265,363.25


                                Sanitary Sewer

                        79      San Sewer, Rem, 6 inch                                       60          Ft               $20.00             $1,200.00

                        80      San Sewer, Rem, 8 inch                                       80          Ft               $20.00             $1,600.00

                        81      Abandon Well in Sanitary Manhole                              1          Ea             $1,000.00            $1,000.00

                        82      Cap Existing DI Sanitary Cleanout Riser                       1          Ea              $500.00               $500.00

                        83      Sanitary Manhole, 48 inch dia                                 3          Ea             $2,750.00            $8,250.00

                        84      San Sewer, 6 inch, Tr Det B                                  63          Ft               $53.50             $3,370.50

                        85      San Sewer, 8 inch, Tr Det B                                  80          Ft               $55.50             $4,440.00

                        86      San Sewer, Connect to 8 inch                                 10          Ea              $250.00             $2,500.00

                                                                                       Sanitary Sewer Subtotal:                            $22,860.50


                                Water Main

                        87      Hydrant, Rem                                                 16          Ea             $1,000.00          $16,000.00

                        88      Hydrant, Adj                                                  2          Ea             $1,750.00            $3,500.00

                        89      Water Main, Valve and Box, 6 inch, Rem                        1          Ea             $3,500.00            $3,500.00

                        90      Water Main, Valve and Box, 8 inch, Rem                        1          Ea             $3,500.00            $3,500.00

                        91      Water Main, Valve and Manhole, 16 inch, Rem                   4          Ea             $5,000.00          $20,000.00

                        92      Water Main, Valve and Manhole, 20 inch, Rem                   1          Ea             $5,000.00            $5,000.00

                        93      Water Main, Valve Manhole, Rem                                1          Ea             $1,000.00            $1,000.00




page 20 of 24                                                                                                     S:\2014\2140401 City of Muskegon\CDS\bid tab 2014-01-27 Muskegon & Webster Ave.xlsx
3355 Evergreen Dr. NE Grand Rapids, MI 49525
t. (616) 364-8491 f. (616) 364-6955
                                                                                                                                                   Bid Tabulation

                     Owner:                                                                              7th
                       City of Muskegon
                     Project Title:                                                                        DJ McQuestion & Sons, Inc.
                                                                                                               17708 18 Mile Road
                       Webster Avenue & Muskegon Avenue Street Reconstruction and Utility Improvements
                                                                                                                LeRoy, MI 49655
                     Bid Date & Time:                                             Project #:
                       January 27, 2015 at 2:00 PM                                  2140401


                     Item No.                         Description                    Quantity     Unit     Unit Price           Total Amount

                        94      Water Main, Abandoned Valve Box, Rem                    33         Ea           $275.00             $9,075.00

                        95      Water Main, Plug, 4 inch                                 1         Ea           $300.00               $300.00

                        96      Water Main, Plug, 6 inch                                 7         Ea           $325.00             $2,275.00

                        97      Water Main, Plug, 8 inch                                 1         Ea           $350.00               $350.00

                        98      Water Main, Cap, 4 inch                                  1         Ea           $325.00               $325.00

                        99      Water Main, Cap, 6 inch                                  6         Ea           $350.00             $2,100.00

                       100      Water Main, Cap or Plug, 6 inch                         26         Ea           $325.00             $8,450.00

                       101      Water Main, Cap or Plug, 8 inch                          3         Ea           $350.00             $1,050.00

                       102      Water Main, Temporary Cap, 6 inch                        7         Ea           $350.00             $2,450.00

                       103      Water Main, Valve Box, Adj                              37         Ea           $250.00             $9,250.00

                       104      Water Main, Meter Box, Adj                               1         Ea           $300.00               $300.00

                       105      Water Main, DI, 4 inch, Tr Det G                        61         Ft            $60.00             $3,660.00

                       106      Water Main, DI, 6 inch, Tr Det G                        191        Ft            $55.00           $10,505.00

                       107      Water Main, DI, 8 inch, Tr Det G                       5,264       Ft            $45.00         $236,880.00

                       108      Water Main, DI, 16 inch, Tr Det G                       30         Ft            $95.00             $2,850.00

                       109      Water Main, DI, 20 inch, Tr Det G                       10         Ft           $115.00             $1,150.00

                       110      Water Main, Valve and Box, 4 inch                        2         Ea           $950.00             $1,900.00

                       111      Water Main, Valve and Box, 6 inch                        9         Ea          $1,100.00            $9,900.00

                       112      Water Main, Valve and Box, 8 inch                       18         Ea          $1,450.00          $26,100.00

                       113      Water Main, Valve and Box, 16 inch                       4         Ea          $2,525.00          $10,100.00

                       114      Water Main, 11 1/4 Degree Bend, 8 inch                   1         Ea           $400.00               $400.00

                       115      Water Main, 45 Degree Bend, 8 inch                      37         Ea           $400.00           $14,800.00

                       116      Water Main, Tee, 8 inch x 8 inch x 6 inch               10         Ea           $575.00             $5,750.00

                       117      Water Main, Tee, 8 inch x 8 inch x 8 inch                1         Ea           $625.00               $625.00

                       118      Water Main, Cross, 8 inch x 8 inch                       3         Ea           $775.00             $2,325.00

                       119      Water Main, Cross, 16 inch x 8 inch                      1         Ea          $1,550.00            $1,550.00




page 21 of 24                                                                                            S:\2014\2140401 City of Muskegon\CDS\bid tab 2014-01-27 Muskegon & Webster Ave.xlsx
3355 Evergreen Dr. NE Grand Rapids, MI 49525
t. (616) 364-8491 f. (616) 364-6955
                                                                                                                                                                 Bid Tabulation

                     Owner:                                                                                            7th
                       City of Muskegon
                     Project Title:                                                                                      DJ McQuestion & Sons, Inc.
                                                                                                                             17708 18 Mile Road
                       Webster Avenue & Muskegon Avenue Street Reconstruction and Utility Improvements
                                                                                                                              LeRoy, MI 49655
                     Bid Date & Time:                                                        Project #:
                       January 27, 2015 at 2:00 PM                                             2140401


                     Item No.                           Description                             Quantity     Unit        Unit Price           Total Amount

                       120      Water Main, Sleeve, 4 inch                                          2         Ea              $600.00             $1,200.00

                       121      Water Main, Sleeve, 6 inch                                          1         Ea              $550.00               $550.00

                       122      Water Main, Sleeve, 8 inch                                         13         Ea              $625.00             $8,125.00

                       123      Water Main, Sleeve, 16 inch                                         8         Ea             $2,500.00          $20,000.00

                       124      Water Main, Sleeve, 20 inch                                         2         Ea             $3,500.00            $7,000.00

                       125      Water Main, Reducer, 8 inch x 6 inch                               11         Ea              $350.00             $3,850.00

                       126      Water Main, Tapping Tee and Valve, 16 inch x 16 inch x              4         Ea             $6,275.00          $25,100.00

                       127      Water Main, Tapping Tee and Valve, 20 inch x 20 inch x 4            2         Ea             $5,825.00          $11,650.00

                       128      Water Main, Tapping Tee and Valve, 20 inch x 20 inch x 6            3         Ea             $6,050.00          $18,150.00

                       129      Fire Hydrant                                                       12         Ea             $3,750.00          $45,000.00

                       130      Investigate Location, Material, and Size of Existing Water         53         Ea              $200.00           $10,600.00

                       131      Water Service, Remove and Plug Existing Tap                         0         Ea                                        $0.00

                       132      Water Service, 1 inch                                             3,175       Ft               $45.00         $142,875.00

                       133      Water Service, 2 inch                                              731        Ft               $52.00           $38,012.00

                       134      Water Service, Corporation Stop, 1 inch                            95         Ea              $175.00           $16,625.00

                       135      Water Service, Corporation Stop, 2 inch                            22         Ea              $425.00             $9,350.00

                       136      Water Service, Curb Stop and Box, 1 inch                           95         Ea              $275.00           $26,125.00

                       137      Water Service, Curb Stop and Box, 2 inch                           22         Ea              $500.00           $11,000.00

                                                                                                Water Main Subtotal:                          $812,132.00


                                Landscaping

                       138      Acer freemani 'Celzam', 2 1/2" cal.                                 9         Ea              $375.00             $3,375.00

                       139      Acer freemani 'Jeffersred', 2 1/2" cal.                            14         Ea              $375.00             $5,250.00

                       140      Acer platanoides 'Crimson King', 2 1/2" cal.                       13         Ea              $325.00             $4,225.00

                       141      Acer rubrum 'Franksred', 2 1/2" cal.                                8         Ea              $385.00             $3,080.00

                       142      Celtis occidentalis 'All Seasons', 2 1/2" cal.                     12         Ea              $400.00             $4,800.00

                       143      Ginko biloba 'Autumn Gold', 2 1/2" cal.                            16         Ea              $355.00             $5,680.00




page 22 of 24                                                                                                          S:\2014\2140401 City of Muskegon\CDS\bid tab 2014-01-27 Muskegon & Webster Ave.xlsx
3355 Evergreen Dr. NE Grand Rapids, MI 49525
t. (616) 364-8491 f. (616) 364-6955
                                                                                                                                                                  Bid Tabulation

                     Owner:                                                                                             7th
                       City of Muskegon
                     Project Title:                                                                                       DJ McQuestion & Sons, Inc.
                                                                                                                              17708 18 Mile Road
                       Webster Avenue & Muskegon Avenue Street Reconstruction and Utility Improvements
                                                                                                                               LeRoy, MI 49655
                     Bid Date & Time:                                                         Project #:
                       January 27, 2015 at 2:00 PM                                              2140401


                     Item No.                             Description                            Quantity      Unit       Unit Price           Total Amount

                       144      Gleditsia t.i. 'Skyline', 2 1/2" cal.                               15         Ea             $275.00              $4,125.00

                       145      Phellodendron amurensis Macho, 2 1/2" cal.                           4         Ea             $355.00              $1,420.00

                       146      Platanus x acerfolia 'Morton Circle Exclamation', 2 1/2" ca         16         Ea             $333.00              $5,328.00

                       147      Pyrus calleryana 'Cleveland select', 2 1/2" cal.                    20         Ea             $285.00              $5,700.00

                       148      Quercus robur 'Fastigiata', 2 1/2" cal.                              3         Ea             $380.00              $1,140.00

                       149      Quercus rubra, 2 1/2" cal.                                           9         Ea             $340.00              $3,060.00

                       150      Syringa reticulata Ivory Silk, 2 1/2" cal.                          10         Ea             $282.00              $2,820.00

                       151      Tilia cordata 'Corzam', 2 1/2" cal.                                  5         Ea             $335.00              $1,675.00

                       152      Ulmus x. Accolade, 2 1/2" cal.                                      20         Ea             $317.00              $6,340.00

                       153      Zelkova serrata 'Green Vase', 2 1/2" cal.                           18         Ea             $335.00              $6,030.00

                       154      Tree Gator Bags, Supply, Install and Fill                           192        Ea               $20.00             $3,840.00

                                                                                                Landscaping Subtotal:                            $67,888.00


                                                                                                            Total Bid                       $5,381,835.00


                                Alternate Bid Items

                       155      Aggregate Base, 8 inch, 21AA                                      50,530       Syd                $8.65        $437,084.50

                       156      Acer freemani 'Celzam', 2" to 2 1/2" cal.                            9         Ea             $275.00              $2,475.00

                       157      Acer freemani 'Jeffersred', 2" to 2 1/2" cal.                       14         Ea             $325.00              $4,550.00

                       158      Acer platanoides 'Crimson King', 2" to 2 1/2" cal.                  13         Ea             $295.00              $3,835.00

                       159      Acer rubrum 'Franksred', 2" to 2 1/2" cal.                           8         Ea             $335.00              $2,680.00

                       160      Celtis occidentalis 'All Seasons', 2" to 2 1/2" cal.                12         Ea             $345.00              $4,140.00

                       161      Ginko biloba 'Autumn Gold', 2" to 2 1/2" cal.                       16         Ea             $314.00              $5,024.00

                       162      Gleditsia t.i. 'Skyline', 2" to 2 1/2" cal.                         15         Ea             $225.00              $3,375.00

                       163      Phellodendron amurensis Macho, 2" to 2 1/2" cal.                     4         Ea             $305.00              $1,220.00

                       164      Platanus x acerfolia 'Morton Circle Exclamation', 2" to 2 1         16         Ea             $285.00              $4,560.00

                       165      Pyrus calleryana 'Cleveland select', 2" to 2 1/2" cal.              20         Ea             $245.00              $4,900.00

                       166      Quercus robur 'Fastigiata', 2" to 2 1/2" cal.                        3         Ea             $335.00              $1,005.00




page 23 of 24                                                                                                           S:\2014\2140401 City of Muskegon\CDS\bid tab 2014-01-27 Muskegon & Webster Ave.xlsx
3355 Evergreen Dr. NE Grand Rapids, MI 49525
t. (616) 364-8491 f. (616) 364-6955
                                                                                                                                                   Bid Tabulation

                     Owner:                                                                              7th
                       City of Muskegon
                     Project Title:                                                                        DJ McQuestion & Sons, Inc.
                                                                                                               17708 18 Mile Road
                       Webster Avenue & Muskegon Avenue Street Reconstruction and Utility Improvements
                                                                                                                LeRoy, MI 49655
                     Bid Date & Time:                                              Project #:
                       January 27, 2015 at 2:00 PM                                   2140401


                     Item No.                           Description                   Quantity    Unit     Unit Price           Total Amount

                       167      Quercus rubra, 2" to 2 1/2" cal.                          9        Ea          $300.00              $2,700.00

                       168      Syringa reticulata Ivory Silk, 2" to 2 1/2" cal.         10        Ea          $235.00              $2,350.00

                       169      Tilia cordata 'Corzam', 2" to 2 1/2" cal.                 5        Ea          $275.00              $1,375.00

                       170      Ulmus x. Accolade, 2" to 2 1/2" cal.                     20        Ea          $280.00              $5,600.00

                       171      Zelkova serrata 'Green Vase', 2" to 2 1/2" cal.          18        Ea          $285.00              $5,130.00

                       * Denotes correction made by Engineer




page 24 of 24                                                                                            S:\2014\2140401 City of Muskegon\CDS\bid tab 2014-01-27 Muskegon & Webster Ave.xlsx

Top of Page


New Agenda Notifications

* indicates required